Haunted Mansion - The Mafia / Ok look / Vulash 21 years ago

Ok look

I don't care if people want to find clues and accuse me - I won't sit here and dispute every clue, but I do fit some of the vaguer ones. I also don't want this to be misconstrued as me pointing fingers soley at someone that points them at me. MEC voted for me and I don't see any reason to suspect him of either Mafia or SK.

This is what I do suspect, however. First Mae was defensive when she got a little heat her way, and rightly so. But then she starts pointing fingers at anyone and everyone with a vague clue to get heat off her. It almost seems desperate. Even then I wasn't convinced, even though she has accused like 8 people now today. I was talking with someone else whom I won't name because they have some motto about loose ships and lips and I got chastised earlier ;p But we were thinking. No one has defended mae or helped to divert the heat at all so maybe she realy is innocent. Even if its subtle if she was mafia someone would do SOMETHING to help save her. But then Immy posted this

immy

I'm sure this post is gonna get me lynched. I considered not voicing my opinion since it sways so much from what everyone else is thinkng, however, I don't want to remain 'too quiet'.

I agree with Mae on the "black" clues. Here is why:
Taken from the death scene of Elegua:
Quote:

Seconds later, their wicks reignited with black flames

In Dustins (vulash) bio:
Quote:
a long black leather trench coat despite the heat, and his fingernails were long, painted blood red, and cut to points. Everything he wore was black, including his freshly dyed hair.

Now...this could, of course, be pure coincedence. But the mention of the flames turning black and Dustin wearing black was something I couldn't overlook.

I've already stated I thought the clue of Ophelia saying, "You!" was directed to the Reverand. I'm not so sure anymore. But, again, as I said in another post, he could possibly be a good liar.

Isaac. I know in every ghost scene - book or movie - there is always a mention of tempatures dropping. But, there just seems to be a strong emphasis on it within the kill scenes. His nickname being 'Icy' makes me wonder. Though, I'm not voting for him yet, simply because I haven't convinced myself fully.

In the first game I was the godfather. It was SOOO much easier then. I didn't have to read into clues as much, worry about watching my back cause I -was- the killer then. And, I'm almost positive me siding with Mae is a shoe in for my death, I just hope the other townies can see this as it is. Me expressing my ideas on the clues.

Ok that still doesn't mean a whole lot by itself. Immy has reason to suspect me, ok thats fine. But then we get this

Immy

After re-reading everything. My vote goes to:

Bob Tilton

Now it would seem obvious to me that the good Reverand isn't the SK. Or rather at least that clues aren't pointing at him, simply him RP'ing his char who hates almost all of us here is pointing at him. Nothing else that I can see or has been brought up. So if Immy has this evidence against me, and thinks that I did it, why vote for Bob?

Because Bob had previous votes, and the only way to save Mae now was to lynch someone else instead - or at least that is how it seems. Immediately following are two more votes for Bob.

Ok so maybe Bob really is guilty, but I dont' see any reason to think he is over anyone else. He just happens to be RP'ing the coolest char in the history of Mafia.

It looks liek a saving tactic to me, but I'm trying to post this with enough time left for Immy to explain if she wants.

Maybe I'm wrong, but this definately feels all wrong.

immy 21 years ago

So if Immy has this evidence against me, and thinks that I did it, why vote for Bob?

Honestly, because I couldn't decide. Bob already had several votes for him, and since I suspected him, it would make sense to vote in hopes of a majority and try to get him lynched. Me voting for you, would still only be one vote for you, obviously not enough to get you lynched.

I've already posted why I thought Bob Tiltan was guilty, so it's not that I'm just all of a sudden voting for him.

You'll probably be my next vote, unless I read something in the next death scenes to change my mind. (or the sk / mafia keel me)

I knew as soon as I agreed with Mae fingers would point to me as Mafia. Which is fine, I half expected it. =) As a townie though, I was merely sticking up for another townie in hopes of keeping her alive. Whether that works or not, we'll soon find out.

It's easier to find someone you think you can trust in this game and coerce back and forth with who you think did what, when you start accusing people in the threads, you get attacked early. Which, again, is to be expected. If I struck a cord with you, it's because you're either 1)innocent and want to save your own ass or 2) guilty and want to save your own ass.

Either way, this is an ass saving game. Even while in PMs with Mae, I was never 100% sure I could trust that she wasn't the SK or Mafia. I just had to hope and re-read EVERY damn thing wrote by everyone.

Vulash, I sincerely understand your post, and would think the exact same thing if I were in your shoes. Guess it's your call if you beleive me to be on your side (given you're a townie) or not.

Fun stuff. :grin:

Grimknot 21 years ago

Dustin

Ok that still doesn't mean a whole lot by itself. Immy has reason to suspect me, ok thats fine. But then we get this

Immy wrote:
After re-reading everything. My vote goes to:

Bob Tilton

So if Immy has this evidence against me, and thinks that I did it, why vote for Bob?

Because Bob had previous votes, and the only way to save Mae now was to lynch someone else instead - or at least that is how it seems. Immediately following are two more votes for Bob.

Yea ok that makes too much sense. Let me think on that. Plus Mae is freaking out with a last minute jihad of finger pointing. Looks to me like the SK took out Elegua to set Bob up as a patsy and Mae and her Mafiosi friends are happy to hang up another townie and get ahead.

Vulash 21 years ago

Ok I missed the part with you accusing Bob prevously so I guess that may change things. So many people to keep up with in this one

If you are indeed a townie why do you trust Mae? I don't believe the blue skin / cold part as really a clue, I voted based soley on how she was acting.

immy 21 years ago

I trust her based off of our PMs back and forth to each other.

Like I said in the above post, it's safer to find someone you hope you can trust and discuss things to try and figure out some clues. When Maes character took Jade to the bathroom to let her borrow make-up...I don't know. That just didn't seem like it would be very mafia-ish.

Just like this whole thread has me rethinking you. Perhaps a clever idea on your part to persuade me...or perhaps you're truly a townie.
Whereas someone else may perceive it as two mafia members 'acting out' in the threads to make themselves seem less guilty.

:?

I'm beginning to be Jade more and more. Clueless.

Vulash 21 years ago

Just don't make a 2nd movie please :(

Mai 21 years ago

ROFL! Very good points you guys.

ROzbeans 21 years ago

FUCK YOU I WAS INNOCENT.

/cries.

ROzbeans 21 years ago

And there better be TITS GALORE in my death scene.

Vulash 21 years ago

I concur