Firefly Mafia Round 4 /ooc discussion
Discuss!

Verileah
19 years ago
Discuss!

duexe
19 years ago
You know, the mafia has been pretty effective (brilliant actually). With the loss of the SK, they are going to have to be more bold. I have yet been able to guess who the targets were.
Pei Pei, save ur breath. I've been privy to your Markophobic blather the last couple of days now. You can't off me, your hoping to get me lynched. You had your chance when I didn't cast any votes.
Pei Pei, save ur breath. I've been privy to your Markophobic blather the last couple of days now. You can't off me, your hoping to get me lynched. You had your chance when I didn't cast any votes.

duexe
19 years ago
You know, the mafia has been pretty effective (brilliant actually). With the loss of the SK, they are going to have to be more bold. I have yet been able to guess who the targets were.
Pei Pei, save ur breath. I've been privy to your Markophobic blather the last couple of days now. You can't off me, your hoping to get me lynched. You had your chance when I didn't cast any votes.
Pei Pei, save ur breath. I've been privy to your Markophobic blather the last couple of days now. You can't off me, your hoping to get me lynched. You had your chance when I didn't cast any votes.
k.owen
19 years ago
Last night, we had a pretty split vote. Ivan, Eliham, and I voting for Alex. Alex, Pei Pei, and Trina voting for Ivan. The mafia was hunting for the SK, and they got him. Pei Pei was pushing her clues, which turned out to be the relevent clues. Thing is, the mafia used one of their hits to take out the more obvious suspect: Judas. When Ivan was lynched and he was exposed as the SK, it broke up the apperance of the three of us voting together as mafia members. In today's hit, it's suggested that we got one mafia member:
So Alex was mafia, Pei Pei appears to be running the show, so who else? Here's what I was thinking last night, and the mafia proved me right: They had to make a hit. Who did they have to choose from? Two people voting against Alex, both accused to be mafia. Two people voting not for Ivan, but still for someone to be accused mafia. One person who didn't vote last night (Layla). He showed allegiance to neither side. Pei Pei and Trina could hit Layla and not make it look too obvious that they were ridding themselves of their enemies without having to out one of their own; they already lost one last night.
So what the heck's been up with Trina? She hasn't done anything suspicious. Exactly! The mafia kept her as low under the radar as possible until they needed to pull her out as a swing vote. The mafia saw one of their members going, so they had her vote for Ivan to at least tie it up.
This is all I have time for on my morning break. More at lunch time when I have a few minutes to read and write some more.
The killer regarded the other conspirator for a long moment after it was all over before speaking, harshly.
So Alex was mafia, Pei Pei appears to be running the show, so who else? Here's what I was thinking last night, and the mafia proved me right: They had to make a hit. Who did they have to choose from? Two people voting against Alex, both accused to be mafia. Two people voting not for Ivan, but still for someone to be accused mafia. One person who didn't vote last night (Layla). He showed allegiance to neither side. Pei Pei and Trina could hit Layla and not make it look too obvious that they were ridding themselves of their enemies without having to out one of their own; they already lost one last night.
So what the heck's been up with Trina? She hasn't done anything suspicious. Exactly! The mafia kept her as low under the radar as possible until they needed to pull her out as a swing vote. The mafia saw one of their members going, so they had her vote for Ivan to at least tie it up.
This is all I have time for on my morning break. More at lunch time when I have a few minutes to read and write some more.
k.owen
19 years ago
Last night, we had a pretty split vote. Ivan, Eliham, and I voting for Alex. Alex, Pei Pei, and Trina voting for Ivan. The mafia was hunting for the SK, and they got him. Pei Pei was pushing her clues, which turned out to be the relevent clues. Thing is, the mafia used one of their hits to take out the more obvious suspect: Judas. When Ivan was lynched and he was exposed as the SK, it broke up the apperance of the three of us voting together as mafia members. In today's hit, it's suggested that we got one mafia member:
So Alex was mafia, Pei Pei appears to be running the show, so who else? Here's what I was thinking last night, and the mafia proved me right: They had to make a hit. Who did they have to choose from? Two people voting against Alex, both accused to be mafia. Two people voting not for Ivan, but still for someone to be accused mafia. One person who didn't vote last night (Layla). He showed allegiance to neither side. Pei Pei and Trina could hit Layla and not make it look too obvious that they were ridding themselves of their enemies without having to out one of their own; they already lost one last night.
So what the heck's been up with Trina? She hasn't done anything suspicious. Exactly! The mafia kept her as low under the radar as possible until they needed to pull her out as a swing vote. The mafia saw one of their members going, so they had her vote for Ivan to at least tie it up.
This is all I have time for on my morning break. More at lunch time when I have a few minutes to read and write some more.
The killer regarded the other conspirator for a long moment after it was all over before speaking, harshly.
So Alex was mafia, Pei Pei appears to be running the show, so who else? Here's what I was thinking last night, and the mafia proved me right: They had to make a hit. Who did they have to choose from? Two people voting against Alex, both accused to be mafia. Two people voting not for Ivan, but still for someone to be accused mafia. One person who didn't vote last night (Layla). He showed allegiance to neither side. Pei Pei and Trina could hit Layla and not make it look too obvious that they were ridding themselves of their enemies without having to out one of their own; they already lost one last night.
So what the heck's been up with Trina? She hasn't done anything suspicious. Exactly! The mafia kept her as low under the radar as possible until they needed to pull her out as a swing vote. The mafia saw one of their members going, so they had her vote for Ivan to at least tie it up.
This is all I have time for on my morning break. More at lunch time when I have a few minutes to read and write some more.

Briare
19 years ago
Your little blurb is laughable really. You just earned my vote though! I have told 2 people my role If I die we all know who Mafia really are.

Briare
19 years ago
Your little blurb is laughable really. You just earned my vote though! I have told 2 people my role If I die we all know who Mafia really are.

duexe
19 years ago
I know this. I'm gonna force the Mafia's hand (somebody's gotta stand up to them). If there are three remaining, I'm toast. If not, we will see. Either way, Mafia's not gonna take me out without a fight.
Pei Pei's been pushing me as a Mafia member. Thing is, I keep getting downgraded as I present relevent facts. She is trivializing it and pushing her psycho-babble.
For those that don't know what I'm talking about...
Marko
Pei Pei
She is avoiding the fact that I didn't vote at all. Mafia or otherwise. My vote would have offed Marconi (and saved myself with no reprecussion if I were Mafia), but instead my fate was decided on a coin toss.
Pei, you have thus played risk free with no votes agenst you. You are obviously a smart (and deadly) veteran player. My question is... What role are you playing?
Dude, YOU'RE Marko. You might not want to do that.
I know this. I'm gonna force the Mafia's hand (somebody's gotta stand up to them). If there are three remaining, I'm toast. If not, we will see. Either way, Mafia's not gonna take me out without a fight.
Pei Pei's been pushing me as a Mafia member. Thing is, I keep getting downgraded as I present relevent facts. She is trivializing it and pushing her psycho-babble.
For those that don't know what I'm talking about...
Marko
I am also not mafia
(why would I input for a mafia hit and do nothing to save myself by simply voting during the lynch). In other words, it doesnt make any sense.
Pei Pei
The fact that you did not vote but there was a mafia hit submitted does not prove that you are not mafia. What it says is that in all likelihood you are not the godfather. Even that isn't iron clad. There are plenty of reasons why you may not have made the vote but still had time to submit a SKID or to vote with the mafia on who to hit. The primary reason would be one adorable 8 month old. You could have missed the vote, but submitted the SKID after midnight. Many do not vote until late to get is much information as possible. A SKID could have been sent in early, and then you could have been waiting to vote only to get side-tracked. There are many other possible explanations for why you missed the vote. The point is you not voting does not prove your innocence.
lol, and before you say it, I have played the game here before. I was the sheriff in the Xmen game so I am familiar with how the SKIDs work.
She is avoiding the fact that I didn't vote at all. Mafia or otherwise. My vote would have offed Marconi (and saved myself with no reprecussion if I were Mafia), but instead my fate was decided on a coin toss.
Pei, you have thus played risk free with no votes agenst you. You are obviously a smart (and deadly) veteran player. My question is... What role are you playing?

duexe
19 years ago
I know this. I'm gonna force the Mafia's hand (somebody's gotta stand up to them). If there are three remaining, I'm toast. If not, we will see. Either way, Mafia's not gonna take me out without a fight.
Pei Pei's been pushing me as a Mafia member. Thing is, I keep getting downgraded as I present relevent facts. She is trivializing it and pushing her psycho-babble.
For those that don't know what I'm talking about...
Marko
Pei Pei
She is avoiding the fact that I didn't vote at all. Mafia or otherwise. My vote would have offed Marconi (and saved myself with no reprecussion if I were Mafia), but instead my fate was decided on a coin toss.
Pei, you have thus played risk free with no votes agenst you. You are obviously a smart (and deadly) veteran player. My question is... What role are you playing?
Dude, YOU'RE Marko. You might not want to do that.
I know this. I'm gonna force the Mafia's hand (somebody's gotta stand up to them). If there are three remaining, I'm toast. If not, we will see. Either way, Mafia's not gonna take me out without a fight.
Pei Pei's been pushing me as a Mafia member. Thing is, I keep getting downgraded as I present relevent facts. She is trivializing it and pushing her psycho-babble.
For those that don't know what I'm talking about...
Marko
I am also not mafia
(why would I input for a mafia hit and do nothing to save myself by simply voting during the lynch). In other words, it doesnt make any sense.
Pei Pei
The fact that you did not vote but there was a mafia hit submitted does not prove that you are not mafia. What it says is that in all likelihood you are not the godfather. Even that isn't iron clad. There are plenty of reasons why you may not have made the vote but still had time to submit a SKID or to vote with the mafia on who to hit. The primary reason would be one adorable 8 month old. You could have missed the vote, but submitted the SKID after midnight. Many do not vote until late to get is much information as possible. A SKID could have been sent in early, and then you could have been waiting to vote only to get side-tracked. There are many other possible explanations for why you missed the vote. The point is you not voting does not prove your innocence.
lol, and before you say it, I have played the game here before. I was the sheriff in the Xmen game so I am familiar with how the SKIDs work.
She is avoiding the fact that I didn't vote at all. Mafia or otherwise. My vote would have offed Marconi (and saved myself with no reprecussion if I were Mafia), but instead my fate was decided on a coin toss.
Pei, you have thus played risk free with no votes agenst you. You are obviously a smart (and deadly) veteran player. My question is... What role are you playing?
k.owen
19 years ago
Trina-
Are you going to simply dismiss my post as nonsense, or are you actually gonna get involved in this game and defend yourself with some logic?
What, other than me accusing you leads you to believe I'm mafia?
Are you going to simply dismiss my post as nonsense, or are you actually gonna get involved in this game and defend yourself with some logic?
What, other than me accusing you leads you to believe I'm mafia?
k.owen
19 years ago
Trina-
Are you going to simply dismiss my post as nonsense, or are you actually gonna get involved in this game and defend yourself with some logic?
What, other than me accusing you leads you to believe I'm mafia?
Are you going to simply dismiss my post as nonsense, or are you actually gonna get involved in this game and defend yourself with some logic?
What, other than me accusing you leads you to believe I'm mafia?

Briare
19 years ago
Show me evidence that specifically says your not?
Why should I argue when there is not logic in your post? Your version of involvement and mine are 2 totally different things. It could be anyone and well you pissed me off so that is how I am voting.
You are taking silence as guilt. Not the most intelligent route in my opinion. Just because I do not speak out loud in this thread doesn’t mean I am not playing the game. Your strategy and mine differ if you are going to preach taking me out for that then go ahead.
Why should I argue when there is not logic in your post? Your version of involvement and mine are 2 totally different things. It could be anyone and well you pissed me off so that is how I am voting.
You are taking silence as guilt. Not the most intelligent route in my opinion. Just because I do not speak out loud in this thread doesn’t mean I am not playing the game. Your strategy and mine differ if you are going to preach taking me out for that then go ahead.

Briare
19 years ago
Show me evidence that specifically says your not?
Why should I argue when there is not logic in your post? Your version of involvement and mine are 2 totally different things. It could be anyone and well you pissed me off so that is how I am voting.
You are taking silence as guilt. Not the most intelligent route in my opinion. Just because I do not speak out loud in this thread doesn’t mean I am not playing the game. Your strategy and mine differ if you are going to preach taking me out for that then go ahead.
Why should I argue when there is not logic in your post? Your version of involvement and mine are 2 totally different things. It could be anyone and well you pissed me off so that is how I am voting.
You are taking silence as guilt. Not the most intelligent route in my opinion. Just because I do not speak out loud in this thread doesn’t mean I am not playing the game. Your strategy and mine differ if you are going to preach taking me out for that then go ahead.
k.owen
19 years ago
You're asking for something that doesn't exist. There's no evidence that specifically says anything. Everything is guess work and following the clues the best you can. And why did you avoid my question by turning it right back at me? I gave my reasoning, however absured you may think it is, already. I have yet to see you give any reasoning in anything.
You could say that you're involvement, or lack thereof, is just your style of play, but I think it's a mafia ploy.
Briare
Show me evidence that specifically says your not?
Why should I argue when there is not logic in your post? Your version of involvement and mine are 2 totally different things. It could be anyone and well you pissed me off so that is how I am voting.
You are taking silence as guilt. Not the most intelligent route in my opinion. Just because I do not speak out loud in this thread doesn’t mean I am not playing the game. Your strategy and mine differ if you are going to preach taking me out for that then go ahead.
You're asking for something that doesn't exist. There's no evidence that specifically says anything. Everything is guess work and following the clues the best you can. And why did you avoid my question by turning it right back at me? I gave my reasoning, however absured you may think it is, already. I have yet to see you give any reasoning in anything.
You could say that you're involvement, or lack thereof, is just your style of play, but I think it's a mafia ploy.
k.owen
19 years ago
You're asking for something that doesn't exist. There's no evidence that specifically says anything. Everything is guess work and following the clues the best you can. And why did you avoid my question by turning it right back at me? I gave my reasoning, however absured you may think it is, already. I have yet to see you give any reasoning in anything.
You could say that you're involvement, or lack thereof, is just your style of play, but I think it's a mafia ploy.
Briare
Show me evidence that specifically says your not?
Why should I argue when there is not logic in your post? Your version of involvement and mine are 2 totally different things. It could be anyone and well you pissed me off so that is how I am voting.
You are taking silence as guilt. Not the most intelligent route in my opinion. Just because I do not speak out loud in this thread doesn’t mean I am not playing the game. Your strategy and mine differ if you are going to preach taking me out for that then go ahead.
You're asking for something that doesn't exist. There's no evidence that specifically says anything. Everything is guess work and following the clues the best you can. And why did you avoid my question by turning it right back at me? I gave my reasoning, however absured you may think it is, already. I have yet to see you give any reasoning in anything.
You could say that you're involvement, or lack thereof, is just your style of play, but I think it's a mafia ploy.

Rae
19 years ago
I am sorry to keep you waiting Marko. I may not have as adorable excuse as you for not being present as much, but i do have a full time job and other responsabilities.
From round two ooc
I asked duexe how he knew the method for how the mafia determined their hits.
First response from duexe
I pointed out that the quote he provided only said that the godfather sent a PM to the mod of who to hit. It did not mention anything about a secret vote. so, i said my question still stood. Pooka tried to help him, though I think she thought I was talking to Peter instead of duexe/Marko. She offered that he may have gotten the idea from past games played on another board. My answer was that if I went to another board I would not assume things worked exactly the same.
Second response from duexe
So much for getting the knowledge from a past game. Also in the same post....
Third answer from duexe
I admitted then and will now, this is a plausilble reason for why he made the secret vote statement. The problem is, he did not say this in the beginning. If this were truly the reason why not just say it instead of posting a quote that did not answer the question. I of course deduced from this that he had to make that excuse up because I would not back down.
His next reasoning for why he is not mafia was that he did not vote.
As I said and he was kind enough to quote above, the fact that he did not vote does not prove his innocence. Trina didn't vote twice, does that make he twice as innocent?A skid could be sent in early, and there are many reasons why someone could miss a vote. duexe provides his..
The problem with trying to find clues to match Marko's bio is that his bio is so short. that doesn't mean it can't be done.
From round two
From Marko's bio
For as short as it is, there are plenty of references to water in his bio. If we were to then follow Jinheim's logic, then the statement about the plan being a wash was made by the godfather. That would make Marko the godfather. He has offered my name for the role, but so far the only evidence he gives is my "attention to detail"
From round two ooc
duexe
Is it some secret vote process similar to how mafia hits are determined?
I asked duexe how he knew the method for how the mafia determined their hits.
First response from duexe
duexe
From Mafia Faq thread
Awesome! How do I kill people?
There are three ways in which player death can occur. The first is the mafia hit, which happens in the morning of each day. The Godfather PMs the mod with the mafia hit. The second is the lynching. Each evening the town comes together and lynches one of its members. This is done by a majority vote, and all players have one vote, including the mafia. In the instance of a tie, the mod will decide randomly whether both or none of the parties in question die..
I pointed out that the quote he provided only said that the godfather sent a PM to the mod of who to hit. It did not mention anything about a secret vote. so, i said my question still stood. Pooka tried to help him, though I think she thought I was talking to Peter instead of duexe/Marko. She offered that he may have gotten the idea from past games played on another board. My answer was that if I went to another board I would not assume things worked exactly the same.
Second response from duexe
duexe
I swear I have never played this before.
So much for getting the knowledge from a past game. Also in the same post....
Third answer from duexe
duexe
Somebody stated there are 3 mafia. Doesn’t make sense that they wouldn’t work cooperatively to chose a target.
I admitted then and will now, this is a plausilble reason for why he made the secret vote statement. The problem is, he did not say this in the beginning. If this were truly the reason why not just say it instead of posting a quote that did not answer the question. I of course deduced from this that he had to make that excuse up because I would not back down.
His next reasoning for why he is not mafia was that he did not vote.
duexe
I am also not mafia
(why would I input for a mafia hit and do nothing to save myself by simply voting during the lynch). In other words, it doesnt make any sense.
As I said and he was kind enough to quote above, the fact that he did not vote does not prove his innocence. Trina didn't vote twice, does that make he twice as innocent?A skid could be sent in early, and there are many reasons why someone could miss a vote. duexe provides his..
duexe
If you remember my rambling on the day of the second town lynching, I was extreamly unfocused (because I was dealing with my 8 month old).
The problem with trying to find clues to match Marko's bio is that his bio is so short. that doesn't mean it can't be done.
From round two
Somehow I doubt that. Guess this plan is a wash in any case,
From Marko's bio
My first memory is washing up beachside on the south shore
Don’t know where the pod went, probably at the bottom of the ocean.
This place seems a little ‘backwater’.
For as short as it is, there are plenty of references to water in his bio. If we were to then follow Jinheim's logic, then the statement about the plan being a wash was made by the godfather. That would make Marko the godfather. He has offered my name for the role, but so far the only evidence he gives is my "attention to detail"

Rae
19 years ago
I am sorry to keep you waiting Marko. I may not have as adorable excuse as you for not being present as much, but i do have a full time job and other responsabilities.
From round two ooc
I asked duexe how he knew the method for how the mafia determined their hits.
First response from duexe
I pointed out that the quote he provided only said that the godfather sent a PM to the mod of who to hit. It did not mention anything about a secret vote. so, i said my question still stood. Pooka tried to help him, though I think she thought I was talking to Peter instead of duexe/Marko. She offered that he may have gotten the idea from past games played on another board. My answer was that if I went to another board I would not assume things worked exactly the same.
Second response from duexe
So much for getting the knowledge from a past game. Also in the same post....
Third answer from duexe
I admitted then and will now, this is a plausilble reason for why he made the secret vote statement. The problem is, he did not say this in the beginning. If this were truly the reason why not just say it instead of posting a quote that did not answer the question. I of course deduced from this that he had to make that excuse up because I would not back down.
His next reasoning for why he is not mafia was that he did not vote.
As I said and he was kind enough to quote above, the fact that he did not vote does not prove his innocence. Trina didn't vote twice, does that make he twice as innocent?A skid could be sent in early, and there are many reasons why someone could miss a vote. duexe provides his..
The problem with trying to find clues to match Marko's bio is that his bio is so short. that doesn't mean it can't be done.
From round two
From Marko's bio
For as short as it is, there are plenty of references to water in his bio. If we were to then follow Jinheim's logic, then the statement about the plan being a wash was made by the godfather. That would make Marko the godfather. He has offered my name for the role, but so far the only evidence he gives is my "attention to detail"
From round two ooc
duexe
Is it some secret vote process similar to how mafia hits are determined?
I asked duexe how he knew the method for how the mafia determined their hits.
First response from duexe
duexe
From Mafia Faq thread
Awesome! How do I kill people?
There are three ways in which player death can occur. The first is the mafia hit, which happens in the morning of each day. The Godfather PMs the mod with the mafia hit. The second is the lynching. Each evening the town comes together and lynches one of its members. This is done by a majority vote, and all players have one vote, including the mafia. In the instance of a tie, the mod will decide randomly whether both or none of the parties in question die..
I pointed out that the quote he provided only said that the godfather sent a PM to the mod of who to hit. It did not mention anything about a secret vote. so, i said my question still stood. Pooka tried to help him, though I think she thought I was talking to Peter instead of duexe/Marko. She offered that he may have gotten the idea from past games played on another board. My answer was that if I went to another board I would not assume things worked exactly the same.
Second response from duexe
duexe
I swear I have never played this before.
So much for getting the knowledge from a past game. Also in the same post....
Third answer from duexe
duexe
Somebody stated there are 3 mafia. Doesn’t make sense that they wouldn’t work cooperatively to chose a target.
I admitted then and will now, this is a plausilble reason for why he made the secret vote statement. The problem is, he did not say this in the beginning. If this were truly the reason why not just say it instead of posting a quote that did not answer the question. I of course deduced from this that he had to make that excuse up because I would not back down.
His next reasoning for why he is not mafia was that he did not vote.
duexe
I am also not mafia
(why would I input for a mafia hit and do nothing to save myself by simply voting during the lynch). In other words, it doesnt make any sense.
As I said and he was kind enough to quote above, the fact that he did not vote does not prove his innocence. Trina didn't vote twice, does that make he twice as innocent?A skid could be sent in early, and there are many reasons why someone could miss a vote. duexe provides his..
duexe
If you remember my rambling on the day of the second town lynching, I was extreamly unfocused (because I was dealing with my 8 month old).
The problem with trying to find clues to match Marko's bio is that his bio is so short. that doesn't mean it can't be done.
From round two
Somehow I doubt that. Guess this plan is a wash in any case,
From Marko's bio
My first memory is washing up beachside on the south shore
Don’t know where the pod went, probably at the bottom of the ocean.
This place seems a little ‘backwater’.
For as short as it is, there are plenty of references to water in his bio. If we were to then follow Jinheim's logic, then the statement about the plan being a wash was made by the godfather. That would make Marko the godfather. He has offered my name for the role, but so far the only evidence he gives is my "attention to detail"

Briare
19 years ago
I pitty the fool who messes with Rae *ha ha - She does remember everything.

Briare
19 years ago
I pitty the fool who messes with Rae *ha ha - She does remember everything.

duexe
19 years ago
I read to the second paragraph and started to fall asleep..
But your information is very effective, it made me want to kill myself...
But your information is very effective, it made me want to kill myself...