Day Two /ooc chatter

Emerald bit it! Discuss!

Vulash 17 years ago
The windex woudl be in the store all over - I think it's more in the knowledge to and how to use it.
vwinsect 17 years ago
true forgot that she had a camera... lol
Rae 17 years ago
I have been posting on the SK because there is already alot of focus on the mafia hits, without a lot of certainty. The SK seems very obvious to me, and I would rather lynch someone I knew was guilty.

Tor is right that Xyrstal's bio has her parents divorce because of her dance. Xrystal is also a teenager. She is working to save money to make her dreams come true. Those clues fit, it is not uncommon for some clues to match more than one.

The other clues however do not match Xrystal.

Notice when Tor was pointing the finger back at me, he neglected two of the clues.

1. Kassidy gave her parents a garden grave. when talking about someone's grave site, how often do you say it was a garden grave? That was not an idle mention by the mods.

2. The SK talks about making the world better. Kassidy's bio specifically talks about how the surviving kids could make the world better.

Neither of those clues can be found in Xrystal's bio. All of the clues together really only match Kassidy.


(ooc: the weather is of course beautiful now. I am going to check my father and grandfather's homes for damage and such this afternoon. Thank you for asking. )

(ooc2: just because I want to hang you, doesn't mean I don't love ya)
Slipnish 17 years ago
Peep this line:

"Funny how people were so willing to go through that little bit of extra trouble just to be able to use the indoor plumbing."

I don't think that points to any teenage girl. That points to people who are used to being outside and away from the comforts of home...

Those people would be:

1. Henry the Homeless Guy.
2. Lincoln Forrester, the Army Ranger.
3. Dr. Anthony Parnell, Geology Professor.

Henry is OBVIOUSLY used to living outside, as his bio clearly states.

Lincoln is an Ex Army Ranger. Serious outdoor training there. Survival type stuff.

Dr. Parnell is a geology prof. You don't study geology by staying indoors. (Admittedly this one is probably a stretch, but I don't see anyone else who fits.) I'm sticking with Henry, and keeping an eye on Lincoln...

At this time, Parnell might be a long shot...

Actually I see more to point at Nickie the Nurse than Parnell the Geologist, but the whole indoor plumbing thing just screams someone who is used to being outside a LOT...

Especially the tone of "Miss Goody Two Shoes" that comes across in the SKs statements. You could certainly get that from the disaffected of society (Henry), or someone who spurns the values of soft living (Lincoln.)
Tor 17 years ago
Yes, but as previously mentioned, Carly is a gardener and doesn't EVERYONE want to make the world a better place? I know clowns do, if no one else. Well, I don't think that Hank does...he seems negative, what with all of the assaults and stolen vehicle.

The trouble right now is that all of the SK clues cross over with others, and plenty folk still fit the bill. Maybe it'll be more definite after the next kill and you'll see it my way.

I'm totally seriously on killing Mr. Henry, though.

((ooc: I know - I am one lovable kinda guy!))
Rae 17 years ago
I'm sorry Slip, but that doesn't make much sense to me. Why would someone who is used to going outdoors be bothered by it now. If they had made a habit of using 'outdoor facilities' in their normal life, then they should be used to it. If that is a clue, it would be more likely that it points to someone who is not used to going outside as they would be the ones most bothered by such conditions and most likely to do something about it.
Rae 17 years ago
yes, everyone might want to make the world better, but they don't all mention it specifically in their bios.

Besides if you aren't the SK then you can see the logic in helping find and lynch the SK first. There are 3 mafia and 1 SK. If we get lucky and lynch a mafia tonight, there will still be two left which means there will still be a mafia hit tomorrow and an SK hit the next day. If we lynch the SK tonight, then there will only be the mafia hit. Twice as many innocent people die as long as the SK lives. This of course makes the mafia's job easier as there will be fewer townies to out-number them and their vote.
Slipnish 17 years ago
Rae;73826
I'm sorry Slip, but that doesn't make much sense to me. Why would someone who is used to going outdoors be bothered by it now. If they had made a habit of using 'outdoor facilities' in their normal life, then they should be used to it. If that is a clue, it would be more likely that it points to someone who is not used to going outside as they would be the ones most bothered by such conditions and most likely to do something about it.


They aren't bothered by it themselves. They are bothered by the fact that it bothers other people. People who are used to "soft" living. The SK even denotes the victim as a "princess" indicating that they have a problem with people who have had advantaged lives...

It's not that the SK has a problem with it themselves, they have a problem with OTHERS who have a problem with it...
Four Winds 17 years ago
Slipnish;73823
Peep this line:

"Funny how people were so willing to go through that little bit of extra trouble just to be able to use the indoor plumbing."

I don't think that points to any teenage girl. That points to people who are used to being outside and away from the comforts of home...

Those people would be:

1. Henry the Homeless Guy.
2. Lincoln Forrester, the Army Ranger.
3. Dr. Anthony Parnell, Geology Professor.

Henry is OBVIOUSLY used to living outside, as his bio clearly states.

Lincoln is an Ex Army Ranger. Serious outdoor training there. Survival type stuff.

Dr. Parnell is a geology prof. You don't study geology by staying indoors. (Admittedly this one is probably a stretch, but I don't see anyone else who fits.) I'm sticking with Henry, and keeping an eye on Lincoln...

At this time, Parnell might be a long shot...

Actually I see more to point at Nickie the Nurse than Parnell the Geologist, but the whole indoor plumbing thing just screams someone who is used to being outside a LOT...

Especially the tone of "Miss Goody Two Shoes" that comes across in the SKs statements. You could certainly get that from the disaffected of society (Henry), or someone who spurns the values of soft living (Lincoln.)


Of course you forget that Lincoln was a Ranger over 30 years ago, I'm sure he's grown used to things like electric lighting, indoor plumbing and colour television. And he was a family man who had made a quite successful living as a watchmaker.


Heh.
Calimaryn 17 years ago
You guys jes wan my cart! All them keychains an plastic pens are temptin!
Vulash 17 years ago
The indoor plumbing is a great clue actually I totally missed that - I just don't have the feeling we are getting the right person by her reactions even though you're right there are plenty of clues. Oh well gut was wrong on Roz so maybe I'm wrong here :P

I still think the waitress overshadowed the hobo stuff though
vwinsect 17 years ago
of course, all nurses need more keys hehe