HM Mafia Hour One /OOC Discussion

Sniffs. I smell a clue. 4 chords meaning there are 4 mafia or at least implying that there are. The serial killer also has a need to cannibalize. Well, that makes for a good after dinner snack.

(more later, I have a dr's appt this morning)

Agree on the 4 mafia part. It holds true to the last 2 games. I read it that the first part of the kill ws the SK and the 2nd part was the mafia so the mafia was the vampire/cannibal type (since they are ghost possessed).

The ghost dude also clinched and unclinched one hand alot. Could this be a clue too? Why wouldn't he be clinching his hands? Is there a bio with something wrong with one arm/hand?

So many characters this time my head my explode lol

Agreed Mae 4 chords 4 mafia. This ones gonna be a toughie cause of so many players

Game one 13 players, 4 of which were mafia (30%).

Game two 15 players, 3 were mafia, one SK (26%).

Game three has 21 players, so in order to remain the same ratio of townie to : mafia/sk , there will either be 5 (24%)or 6 (28%) non townies (Thinking 5 though).

This next set of info is based on the fact that potentialy Verileah will pick mafia/sk from a pool of people who haven't been a sk/mafia yet.
(Yes I know its ugly)

Name --------------------- Role in Game 1 ---------------------Roll in Game 2 ---------------------Playing game 3?


Danq---------------------Sheriff---------------------- N/A --------------------- No
RasberryTart ---------------------Doctor ---------------------Godfather ---------------------Playing
Aramous ---------------------Townie --------------------- Townie ---------------------Playing
Larene ---------------------Townie ---------------------Townie ---------------------Playing
Mae ---------------------Townie ---------------------SK ---------------------Playing
Aziyade ---------------------Townie ---------------------Townie ---------------------No
Nards ---------------------Townie ---------------------N/A ---------------------No
Vulash ---------------------Townie ---------------------Sheriff ---------------------Playing
Yalelini ---------------------Townie ---------------------N/A ---------------------No
Immy ---------------------Godfather --------------------- N/A ---------------------playing
Nalla --------------------- Mafia --------------------- N/A ---------------------NO
Stormystone ---------------------Mafia ---------------------N/A ---------------------No
Rikr ---------------------Mafia ---------------------N/A ---------------------NO
Jinheim ---------------------N/A ---------------------Mafia ---------------------Playing
Pharren ---------------------N/A ---------------------Mafia ---------------------No
Geei ---------------------N/A ---------------------Doctor ---------------------N/A
MEC ---------------------N/A ---------------------Townie --------------------- Playing
Elvaiz --------------------- N/A ---------------------Townie ---------------------Playing
Pulvani --------------------- N/A ---------------------Townie ---------------------No
Mileron ---------------------N/A ---------------------Townie ---------------------No
Etric --------------------- N/A ---------------------Townie --------------------- Playing
T_Smith ---------------------N/A --------------------- Townie ---------------------No
GoofBall ---------------------N/A ---------------------N/A --------------------- playing
Grimknot ---------------------N/A --------------------- N/A ---------------------Playing
Slipnish ---------------------N/A --------------------- N/A ---------------------playing
Maewyn ---------------------N/A ---------------------N/A ---------------------playing
Tornt --------------------- N/A ---------------------N/A ---------------------Playing
Mushizo ---------------------N/A --------------------- N/A ---------------------playing
Eve --------------------- N/A ---------------------N/A ---------------------playing
David Bowles ---------------------N/A --------------------- N/A ---------------------playing
Krassus --------------------- N/A --------------------- N/A ---------------------playing

Draw your own conclusions....

Piano might be a clue as well... we've got a French rockstar in this room. I need to look back over my notes... christ, why didn't I bring my laptop? Least I know shorthand, or this'd suck like Deep Throat after five years of imposed celibacy.

You don't just jump on a piano and play a full chord. Killer is a musician.

Agreed. I'm inclined to go with Monsieur le Rockstar.

Don't forget that the mafia are possessed by ghosts so the person possessed doesn't necessarily have to be a musician, but the ghost might be.

I do agree with the idea that the 4 notes = 4 mafia. If you look at the ratios Elvaiz posted and conclude there are 5 non-townies, that would equal 4 mafia and 1 SK since the SK is not mafia.

Although should be noted that I dont think four notes is a full chord, I think you need five... but might have just been adapted to fit with the four mafia. Still thinking musician.

I agree about the muscian.
Another thing I noticed too, was this:


To me this says the killer is someone with loud shoes. Why else would it be mentioned that Victor could have heard them approaching had he not been preoccupied?
I'm in a rush right now, but I know some of the characters have loud shoes. Will have to post more after I pick up my son from school.

Don't forget that Dustin is a DJ who once had a band, he is also a musician.

I just skimmed all the characters and can't find anything to support my hand theory. The only one I remember right off that mentioned shoes that would be loud is Jinheim, and I don't think that clue points at his cowboy boots at all as much as I'd LIKE TO LYNCH THE MOTHERFUCKER FOR THE LAST GAME

Time to reread the death scene!

I think the hand flexing thing is just him testing his new body, kinda like you would see on TV.

I think your right MEC I just thought it might be something because it wsa so specific about the one. Oh well.

That puts us back down to the music part only atm which puts me as a suspect goddammit =/ Now I know how Aramous felt in the first 2 games lol.

I do have a funny thought on the hand thing. Hi porn star - one muscular arm. No I'm not serious but found it funny

I C you feeling the luving already.

Feeling kinda sux

I think that it would have to be someone who walks loud enough to hear but yet smoothly enough to surpise.

I know the feeling, one mafia game I was implicated right of the bat, and I was a townie. Aswe found out in the end, the mod had decided it would be fun to mess with us and never put any clues in.

What a mean mod.

:X.

Perhaps the hand twitching does have merit as a nervous habit... this would go back to implicating the poor French rock star.. but I'm a kid.. wad do I know?

Could one not play a chord with 3 notes, and not 4?