Round One: OOC

Well I can't say or do anything to change your minds at this point, or at least nothing I haven't pointed out already.

But should you lynch me tonight, please look back over the advice I've tried to give and use it to root out the actual Mafia and win and stuff.

It's honest advice, and I haven't done anything today except try to cut through layers of doubt and find out who the bad guys are. I wouldn't do that if I were one of 'em.

Will be afk for a little while, so I may not see what is most likely my inevitable lynching, but cheers anyhow. :)

Wow, this is intense. Forgive me for my wideeyedness, but this is my first time ever doing a mafia. But enough about me, lets get to the theories.

So far to me Emilio and Domo have the most evidence pointing at them.

With Emilio what stood out the most to me was the persuasion, his ability to wiggle his way out of trouble by blaming his brother. Making the murder look like a suicide really coinsides with this to me.

With Domo the "but I will live on as the shepard fo deat." really stands out. The problem is the spelling of Shepard. I read earlier that Sheppard was spelled this way purpousfully. So the mud is thickened.

Another person who has been poked at a bunch is Dantes. The Parkour puts a light on in my wittle noggin, all the sneaking around in the death scene would fit. But then I haven't read through the bios yet, so that is deffinately a very dim light.

Forgive me for any mistakes, spelling wasn't my best subject.

MEC: why do you think dantes is the godfather?

The first thing I noticed for the mafia was the word fantasy. It wouldn't mean much except that it was used so many times in the mafia portion. In the SK section it was used only once. In the mafia part it was mentioned four times.

From b]Eduardo's[/b]




Fantasy world/fantasy game, certainly looks like a connection.

The other thing that grabbed my attention right away was this from the hit:



From ABAY's bio:



Another thing to note, is Pooka said that she did not believe in going after the SK right away. That seems suspicious to me. The only ones who want the SK to stick around are the SK and the mafia who need the SK to help kill townies.

From the hit, there appears to be indications of someone being tall. There is also the frequent mention of Giant's Drink. The following are listed as tall.

Dantes - Height: 5’9, Tall for his age with an athletic build.
Lynn - Height: Tall

In the hit there are multiple references to feet. From Michael Andrew's bio:



Also, the way the mafia speaks to Pinual could indicate a "By-the-book" commander. More to the point, a drill sergent type. For such types, it is not uncommon to use insulting names to break someone and bring them in line. The marching could also indicate a group whose commander is "By-the-book".

the giant's drink is only mentioned because in the book it is implied that it had something to do with Pinual's suicide

Emilio is not the only one who has gifts of persuasion. In Janie's bio there is this:

I have not read the book so I found it odd that it was mentioned several times.

she doesnt have the height or combat training to supplement it though (i was going to list her but discarded it as she is not physically capable (ostensibly) of killing someone up to twice her height).

that fantasy link is strong though. i dont see how i completely missed this gem:

HUGE NEON SIGN POINTING AT EDUARDO right there

It was already established pre-kill that Pinual was obsessed with the Giant's drink.
Edit to add: darn it, you beat me too it.

My first post describes my feelings that Dantes is the Godfather, I really feel that there is just way too much theory on the SK for me to pinpoint who I think it is, although for the record I'm leaning towards Eduardo right now.

I would also like to add that I don't think that having any marksmanship abilities apply one for the mafia, they stated that Pinual was the lowest on the standings, thus any single individual would feel that he was bringing them down.

Another thing is the sneakiness factor, the SK has to be sneaky, it's part of the role. Just having being sneaky in one's proile doesn't link you to be the SK.

lol, I had tons of clues for the SK. You should take a look. :p

i still dont buy into the "answer" clue, but some others there cannot be ignored.

im changing my vote.

Dantes has a lot of evidence against him. the mafia link with him is pretty solid, probably moreso than blackrabbits potential SK links. something mentioned earlier made me question some other people, and then in light of recent information, it all sort of clicked in a new way for me.

the fantasy / split personality link i quoted above regarding Eduardo is too powerful for me to ignore. so i start to look at Eduardo's actions. hes joining Dantes in bringing down Emilio? interesting.

im having a hard time formulating my thoughts because im tired so bear with me. im changing my vote to Dantes because of the clues, and because of the way people seem to be protecting him. to me, it looks like everyone other than me (obviously!), Domo (whos vote was changed after some evidence against Emilio surfaced), and Britt (who voted too late to be in cahoots - maybe) who voted for Emilio is mafia or SK in league with mafia, trying to deflect the attention on Dantes and take out somebody who must have hit upon a truth.

i have my eye on Emilio still, and Eduardo for certain. but Dantes, i am convinced, is mafia.

I feel it is my modly duty to inform you that it was Rose de Nose, commander of Rat army, who used to sleep in the barracks with his soldiers because he was afraid of the dark.

The above is in no way a clue. I'm just sayin'.

That's exactly what I mean, so much for the SK, when his part of the kill is so short, it's just so confusing.

As for the fantasy aspects of the mafia part, it definably seems more like dementia, possibly pertaining to either Domo or Eduardo.

Edit to add: Thank you Verileah, now if I can only get my book from North Carolina.

if i am dead tomorrow it means that i was on to something. maybe. i dont know anymore, i just confused the hell out of myself. :( i realized its not very likely that Theresa and Dantes are both mafia

Lol Pharren you are not the only one who is confused. There is just so much information :confused My head is spinning with all the different info it's starting to run together and I can't remember who is who. I think that is a sign for me to go to bed.

i think i'm about as confused as confused could be at the moment... so i better go vote!

That was from one of the teacher's internal narratives, wasn't it?

Wow, now I'm second guessing myself. There are so many speculations being thrown around and possible clues to consider. This is the most intense RP anything that I've ever done, and do I love it!!

Id blame it on your small brain.

yes...clue gathering and discussing should take place earlier..this last minute stuff is for the birds :P