Hogwarts Mafia Round 3 - OOC Discussion

I'm pretty sure that bios are taken into account when roles are decided. It's not a major deciding factor, mind you, but it's not totally random either.

Incidentally, I think your sheriff theory is pretty sound. The whole setting up of patrols and wondering who to trust is solid. I think we got the wrong prefect yesterday.

As for pointing the cannon at Ema with her not around, her post was not up when I started my reply. Started typing and she got hers done first and nipped out while I was rereading her bio, checking Dexter's posts from yesterday and making sure I'd a clue from each round. Besides, she'll be back this evening well before vote time to disarm my clues, no doubt.

Ok, here we go. Being tall is not, to me, a good enough reason to lynch me (check pookas vote). Never at any point did i say IN MY BIO that Simon was dishelved or disorganized. He's quiet, goes from point a to point b for the most part. Although he doesn't talk to a lot of people, that doesn't mean he ignores them. On the contrary Simon is friendly if spoken to, he just doesn't say much and doesn't fall into a crowd. Which is not to say he's the SK either. I still think Angelina was the SK, not the sheriff. Mostly because she was the sheriff in her first and only other game.

Who's to say I'm not the sheriff?

Are you? In any case, your interpretation of your bio isn't relevant, but the mod's inclusion (or not) of elements from it in SK kills.

No, I'm not the sheriff.

Do people always post the truth in here?

yes.. all the time :devil

No, they dont. But seriously...tall and aloof. Could ya'll PLEASE pick better clues to lynch me with? =/

Try the mention of things being 'nicked' - anyone prone to sticky fingers?

The mention of charms. Dark arts. Simon has neither of these. Oh no wait, he's tall and aloof - KEEL!!!!

:teehee

OK people listen up please... I do not think Simon / Roz is mafia becuase I don't see enough clues to that ATM. However I do have a viable suspect for Mafia : Egon Locke

Here's my reasons, based off of clues y'all have been harping on even :

1) He is 6'1. There are only 3 people who are this tall, and that is the tallest height of anyone.
2) In his satchel is a sneak-o-scope. There are mentions of thiefly goings on inside the mafia to obtain the map and other items.
3) His bio mentions his taking the OWLs. There have been several mentions of owls in the mafia threads.
4) His bio describes him as dark, brooding and serious.
5) Day 2 Mafia Alex mentions Artithmancy specifically. The only other person to have this as a favorite subject is Egon.
6) Day 2 Mafia - water seems to be mentioned a couple of times for the owl and why it came back. A locke is a body of water....

a Loch is a body of water... and a Locke is a nothing
but the

thing is pretty damming to me..

and targeting Simon for the given reasons sounds weak to me.. sounds like the Mafia are trying to convine us all to do their dirty work.

Okies...my turn for defense it looks like.

Egon is tall. I agree. I also don't feel that it is something to lynch someone for.

A Sneakoscope is a device that detects folks that are untrustworthy - Sneakoscope

The OWLs are the tests for Ordinary Wizarding Levels. That means he did well in his tests. Note the caps. :) The OWLs and NEWTs

Dark, brooding and serious, yes. So are many from Ravenclaw and Slytherin.

Alex was killed by the Mafia - the fact that we both like the same classes should be evidence to support my innocence, not my guilt.

It is also short for Lockheart, as listed in the bio.

Most of your accusation is based off of false conclusions, so no harm done. Well, hopefully no harm done. Cheers!

if you can prove to me that you are not mafia or the SK I will change my vote. As for getting better clues on you... well I go by 3 things.. 1- what I read. 2- what I hear. 3- what my gut tells me.

Egon looks waaay more guilty than Simon does. Aside from being 'aloof' /rolls eyes, Egon fits more of the clues so that's who I'm voting for.

I'm waiting on Vulesh and Rae before I post... I want to see what they come up with...

I still find Rorri very suspicious, and now Elsie has found more evidence to back up what I said yesterday

Moo? ;)

Sounds like someone is getting her friends to cover for her... (Mae)

You guys vote and it all plays out before I get home from work :(

I just read everythijn g- will start pouring soon

For the record - I absolutely do no Trust Simon this game - call it a gut feeling, but it's there mixed with how I've seen Roz play in the past versus this time (both as her the SK and townie)

--Simon
If Angelina were the SK, there wouldn't have been a kill today. Unless you subscribe to the theory that the SK role is moveable, which I don't.