hmy Little dirty birdy feet 
EWWWWW! that's just nasty Rae, did it remind you of Mai's birdie? EWWW! LOL, I probably would have used a slingshot
I have to reread that one so it makes some sense to me and look for clues.
Round 7 - OOC
Discuss
Hiejinx
16 years ago
EWWW! hmy Little dirty birdy feet EWWWWW!
that's just nasty Rae, did it remind you of Mai's birdie? EWWW! LOL, I probably would have used a slingshot
I have to reread that one so it makes some sense to me and look for clues.
hmy Little dirty birdy feet EWWWWW! that's just nasty Rae, did it remind you of Mai's birdie? EWWW! LOL, I probably would have used a slingshot
I have to reread that one so it makes some sense to me and look for clues.
lemmy101
16 years ago
Damn, another townie bites the dust.
Verileah
16 years ago
Aw, poor birdie. I'm sure we all thought he would die of suffocation after being hugged by a particularly buxom pirate. *sniffs*
Don't worry, your legacy will live on!
Don't worry, your legacy will live on!
Hiejinx
16 years ago
that Olive was all that caught my eye and the only olive skin mentioned is Captain Blackwater. Oh black water... sorry a little CCR going for me there.
what good is saying 6 of something if we don't know lol how many are gone or how many are left? I
am assuming 2, be it 2 mafia, or 1 mafia and 1 SK since 2 was the operative number in mafia hit #6.
BTW, what good is leaving a gourmet roasted birdy for a fellow that can't see it?
-------------------------------
Pinky, are you pondering what I'm pondering?
what good is saying 6 of something if we don't know lol how many are gone or how many are left? I
am assuming 2, be it 2 mafia, or 1 mafia and 1 SK since 2 was the operative number in mafia hit #6.
BTW, what good is leaving a gourmet roasted birdy for a fellow that can't see it?
-------------------------------
Pinky, are you pondering what I'm pondering?
Verileah
16 years ago
Maybe he can smell it?
Does this mean Nick is innocent btw? I mean, I think it would be bad form to roast your fellow mafioso's bird, but we -are- dealing with pirates here.
Does this mean Nick is innocent btw? I mean, I think it would be bad form to roast your fellow mafioso's bird, but we -are- dealing with pirates here.
lemmy101
16 years ago
Tomorrow, Rosa must pay for this poor parrot's demise.
MashPotato
16 years ago
...and why would that be? 
You seem awfully sure of yourself, there.
You seem awfully sure of yourself, there.
lemmy101
16 years ago
I would be, as you say, pretty sure about such things. 
Verileah
16 years ago
Can I just be pretty? *flutters eyelashes*
MashPotato
16 years ago
From that response, you're either mafia or the sheriff, and the sheriff wouldn't accuse me of being mafia
I would be, as you say, pretty sure about such things.
lemmy101
16 years ago
That's exactly who the sheriff would accuse you of being, Ms. Rosa.
Also, I think it's been established that I'm not Mafia. Well, either not Mafia, or the greatest tactical genius mafia player ever pulling off a fake mafia hit/save in round 2. Damn, I wish that were true.
Also, I think it's been established that I'm not Mafia. Well, either not Mafia, or the greatest tactical genius mafia player ever pulling off a fake mafia hit/save in round 2. Damn, I wish that were true.
MashPotato
16 years ago
But I notice you haven't been hit since. Why would a person who's been going on and on about being the sheriff since round 2 not been hit again until even round seven?
I don't know how you managed to do it, but you could have convinced the doctor to save you once, and establish your innocence forever. I know I was fooled
I don't know how you managed to do it, but you could have convinced the doctor to save you once, and establish your innocence forever. I know I was fooled
lemmy101
16 years ago
Because I told you who I was IDing each time. When FourWinds was IDed as Mafia near the start, I get hit the same day. All the other days I also told you who I was IDing, and they come back as NOT MAFIA. Funnily enough I don't get hit on those days.
Also, I was careful enough to muddy the waters as much as possible as to how many doc saves I'd had on me.
Also, I was careful enough to muddy the waters as much as possible as to how many doc saves I'd had on me.
MashPotato
16 years ago
That makes no sense... why would the mafia WAIT until mafia are being ID'd to hit you? They'd hit you before you could ID anyone!
lemmy101
16 years ago
1) In case they waste another hit on a doctor save.
2) Because AFAIK you probably wouldn't get an ID if you got mafia hit the same day, so knowing in advance who the sheriff was IDing basically makes them relatively safe unless they're gonna ID a mafia. In which case you'd whack them and keep their identity safe.
3) So that later in the game they can point that out to try and get the rest of the town to lynch him as some devious mafia.
4) If the Sheriff has no guilty IDs, then they are little more than a standard townie, and so they may end up voting for townies in the lynch by mistake... the Sheriff (or someone who is confirmed to know him)'s word carries weight, so they could have feasibly helped lynch a couple of townies since Four Winds by mistake. That works in Mafia's favour.
5) They don't believe I am the sheriff, and are donating their time to tracking down the real sheriff.
They all seem to be solid reasons to keep a "sheriff" alive... I'm sure there are plenty more reasons
Fact is, you need to be deaded tomorrow.
2) Because AFAIK you probably wouldn't get an ID if you got mafia hit the same day, so knowing in advance who the sheriff was IDing basically makes them relatively safe unless they're gonna ID a mafia. In which case you'd whack them and keep their identity safe.
3) So that later in the game they can point that out to try and get the rest of the town to lynch him as some devious mafia.
4) If the Sheriff has no guilty IDs, then they are little more than a standard townie, and so they may end up voting for townies in the lynch by mistake... the Sheriff (or someone who is confirmed to know him)'s word carries weight, so they could have feasibly helped lynch a couple of townies since Four Winds by mistake. That works in Mafia's favour.
5) They don't believe I am the sheriff, and are donating their time to tracking down the real sheriff.
They all seem to be solid reasons to keep a "sheriff" alive... I'm sure there are plenty more reasons
Fact is, you need to be deaded tomorrow.
MashPotato
16 years ago
1) I'll give you that. However, a more likely explanation is that you're mafia, and of course they wouldn't want to REALLY hit you
2) all the more reason why mafia SHOULD have hit you when they knew you were identifying townies. If you were publicizing who you were planning on IDing to loads of people, that would look rather suspicious if they hit you before a mafia was ID'd.
3) I don't think you're really being serious with this one
4) that's a huge gamble on the mafia's part. You might help lynch a townie, but by being alive you're eliminating suspects. I don't think the benefit of that outweighs the cost!
5) but if you were acting as a shield, then eliminating you would almost be as good because you wouldn't be able to act as a rallying point for the townies.
But if you think about it, what evidence is there that Lemmy is not mafia besides the doctor save?
lemmy101;95128
1) In case they waste another hit on a doctor save.
2) Because AFAIK you probably wouldn't get an ID if you got mafia hit the same day, so knowing in advance who the sheriff was IDing basically makes them relatively safe unless they're gonna ID a mafia. In which case you'd whack them and keep their identity safe.
3) So that later in the game they can point that out to try and get the rest of the town to lynch him as some devious mafia.
4) If the Sheriff has no guilty IDs, then they are little more than a standard townie, and so they may end up voting for townies in the lynch by mistake... the Sheriff (or someone who is confirmed to know him)'s word carries weight, so they could have feasibly helped lynch a couple of townies since Four Winds by mistake. That works in Mafia's favour.
5) They don't believe I am the sheriff, and are donating their time to tracking down the real sheriff.
1) I'll give you that. However, a more likely explanation is that you're mafia, and of course they wouldn't want to REALLY hit you
2) all the more reason why mafia SHOULD have hit you when they knew you were identifying townies. If you were publicizing who you were planning on IDing to loads of people, that would look rather suspicious if they hit you before a mafia was ID'd.
3) I don't think you're really being serious with this one
4) that's a huge gamble on the mafia's part. You might help lynch a townie, but by being alive you're eliminating suspects. I don't think the benefit of that outweighs the cost!
5) but if you were acting as a shield, then eliminating you would almost be as good because you wouldn't be able to act as a rallying point for the townies.
Let me say this: I believed that Lemmy was the sheriff, and so did a lot of people, I think.
But if you think about it, what evidence is there that Lemmy is not mafia besides the doctor save? Let me say this: I believed that Lemmy was the sheriff, and so did a lot of people, I think.
I didn't even consider it until he accused me... maybe that's why the "sheriff" hasn't been revealing any information to the townies!
lemmy101
16 years ago
The claimed Sheriff has revealed info to the townies. He was just protecting certain others from being outted as "Been IDed" as by elimination it would lead unsavoury people to a) the doctor or b) the real sheriff.
What is really the more likely scenario here?
a) The fake sheriff mafia who convinced the doc to save him on round 2 gets a townie lynched round 3, then waits 4 rounds before getting someone lynched on round 7?
b) Or, The sheriff (or proxy to sheriff) got saved on round 2, IDed FourWinds on round 3, then had no other info on guilty parties until round 7, when he finally has another mafia head to throw to the dogs?
Are people really expected to believe scenario a happened over scenario b?
What is really the more likely scenario here?
a) The fake sheriff mafia who convinced the doc to save him on round 2 gets a townie lynched round 3, then waits 4 rounds before getting someone lynched on round 7?
b) Or, The sheriff (or proxy to sheriff) got saved on round 2, IDed FourWinds on round 3, then had no other info on guilty parties until round 7, when he finally has another mafia head to throw to the dogs?
Are people really expected to believe scenario a happened over scenario b?
MashPotato
16 years ago
Waiting has its benefits. Had you accused a townie of being mafia early on, the question of whether you were mafia or not would have arisen much, much sooner. There are 9 people left, a substantial number of those could easily be mafia (I have no idea what's what now). By laying low until late in the game, you make yourself more believable, and can pick off townies with less fuss with all the mafia behind you.
I don't know the exact odds, but for the sheriff not to have made one ID in four tries, with the dwindling numbers of players, does seem unlikely.
lemmy101;95133
a) The fake sheriff who convinced the doc to save him on day 2 gets someone lynched day 3, then waits 4 days before getting someone lynched on day 7?
Waiting has its benefits. Had you accused a townie of being mafia early on, the question of whether you were mafia or not would have arisen much, much sooner. There are 9 people left, a substantial number of those could easily be mafia (I have no idea what's what now
). By laying low until late in the game, you make yourself more believable, and can pick off townies with less fuss with all the mafia behind you.I don't know the exact odds, but for the sheriff not to have made one ID in four tries, with the dwindling numbers of players, does seem unlikely.
lemmy101
16 years ago
I should point out at this stage that I told Mash I was going to ID Darsa, and Darsa was then IDed (NOT MAFIA) and the same day Darsa got Mafia hit.
This was stage 2 of my suspicions, stage 1 being where out of pure curiosity I put forward the proposal that I'd ID Mash *just to clear her* and get her into the "ok club"... and she artfully redirected the attention to MEC. (NOT MAFIA) and even probed for the names of "the OK club" since basically she's "pretty much probably ok" or something similar, despite me saying the rules for entry were a NOT MAFIA ID
Note this was when the amount of IDs that had been made at the time was small enough that it meant that the protected special role in the clan would easily have been figured out if I had given that list of names.
Re: your comments. The truth will out. The Mafia will be destroyed, haha! Will rebuke later after food.
This was stage 2 of my suspicions, stage 1 being where out of pure curiosity I put forward the proposal that I'd ID Mash *just to clear her* and get her into the "ok club"... and she artfully redirected the attention to MEC. (NOT MAFIA) and even probed for the names of "the OK club" since basically she's "pretty much probably ok" or something similar, despite me saying the rules for entry were a NOT MAFIA ID
Note this was when the amount of IDs that had been made at the time was small enough that it meant that the protected special role in the clan would easily have been figured out if I had given that list of names.
Re: your comments. The truth will out. The Mafia will be destroyed, haha! Will rebuke later after food.
nickenstien
16 years ago
All that said, I would just like to add:
DOMONIIIIIIIIICCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!!!! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!! *I am miming that, as I have no voice*. But.......
DOMONIIIIIIIIICCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!!!! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!! *I am miming that, as I have no voice*. But.......