Hogwarts Mafia Round 4 OOC Discussion

ooooo so the SK is down! Thanks mafia.. *snickers*

death by wand suffocation... .....i'm speechless...

Simon was a bad choice... for that I feel bad. I trusted my gut and I was wrong. Good thing about trusting your gut is.. once you get your guts torn out you dont have them TO trust anymore!

I will have to rethink about all the clues I have seen.

Ah yes, the SK is gone, but the amulet still remains, a nice and shiny object of no little value...

So...is the SK really gone?



Laha

We did get one clue though... One of the Mafia is a GIRL!!!

or a gay boy...

EEK!

Laha

which do you fall under Laha?

Ok. Could someone actually level some charges at me? Right now I stand accused of being tall, a body of water, that I've taken the mandatory tests for a year five student and having an item that keeps folks honest around me. You guys feel bad about Simon yesterday...so how about not making the same mistake twice and really LOOKING at the clues that you have before going off half cocked again today.

Since I have some free time, I'll be levelling my own accusations. I was remarkably non-present for the bulk of the voting yesterday, so hopefully people will listen and use those brains for something other than keeping their ears apart! Cheers!

well....wow

I guess Roz was telling the truth - and we are down a doctor, and a sheriff.

That also means that Temprah and Vudu are probably definately townie. They defended Roz far more then a mafia would even if they were playing a ruse.

And the hit on Rae is very interesting. Either one of hte people she mentioned in her last thread is mafia (or more of them) or it's a frame job.

There is a definate trend this game of doing a quick glance over then voting and forgetting. Meaning people vote early then the discussion quits and we aren't getting anywhere really fast.

Yeah.. i *am* a townie...! Ok, right now we are down to 20 people, of whom probably 6 are mafia. That means just under 1/3 are mafia.. which would put the odds in our favor if we can read the clues.

all tall bodies of water must die!

So let's do some clue reading instead of lynching tall drinks of water.

The hard part is now mafia will control 1/3 of the votes. It's going ot make it very rough for us to finish on top.

I am a townie and after looking over what Rae says I HIGHLY recomend everyone else to as well. 99.99999999999% of her stuff makes sense.

*here since I do not want to cut and paste.

http://www.theangrycrayon.com/forum/showthread.php?t=6441&page=5

I thought most of Rae's accusations were pretty weak it was just in a good format

You also didn't believe Mae and who was wrong then?

Plus we now know she was the SK - how much did she really care about accuracy, and how much was simply heat deflection. When I was the SK I framed people to keep the lynches going the way I wanted.

Alot of people were wrong about Mae - Of course I didn't believe her, she is sneaky and very good. It just turns out this time she was telling the truth - not sure how that is a basis to dismiss anything i say

I can stop posting, and simply vote - because I've had no end of people being actually pissed off and snippy at me, and honestly it isnt making this very fun. It's definately a different crowd then the old days. Not that thats bad, but it's bad for me.

Well, I'm still having a hell of a time understanding it all.

I find the story fun to read, and I'm trying to read bios and look for clues that point to people, but for everyone I think I find, someone comes along to discredit it - logically, but still frustrating! lol

It does seem to get rather heated at times though, and if any of that heat were being directed at me, I'm sure I'd feel the same way as Vulash. Being that this game is so big, it might not be the ideal one to have started with but I'm going to keep trying.

Maybe by the time its over it will all fall into place...:S Going back to read, again