Hogwarts Mafia Round 4 OOC Discussion

Chat away!

duexe 18 years ago
Why are you doing that?

As a research tool mostly. I found myself copying and pasting to word and searching that way for key words. I just decided that it was just as well if I posted it for everyone to use...

I work very hard to be lazy...
pooka 18 years ago
If you check the voting summaries, Dexter and Poppy have both always voted for innocent people. I mean, I have been tragically wrong before, but I have a feeling we are lynching a townie again (in voting for Rorri).
Den 18 years ago
Ok -- considering I don't know wtf I'm doing...it is highly possible Rorri is innocent...or Egon...or Elise...until I understand better how to read clues, I'm going to continue to go with my instincts.

Btw...I still don't know who the sheriff is or was...:S
Den 18 years ago
Besides that...if you look at your own list, it appears several people have always voted for innocents.

Oh yea...how do you know if someone is innocent or not?
Tor 18 years ago
Dexter voted for the Serial Killer in round two...I wouldn't consider that an innocent person. He also happens to be the only one who has.

Poppy had a by, voted for you, then for Simon. Last round is somewhat a wash since both Simon and I were innocent, so everyone voted for innocent folks last round.

So far, everyone that's been lynched seems like a townie to me, so that's not necesarily a strong limiting factor. I'm not sold on Rorri, either, but I'll vote that way if it gets me out of the fire. Of course, I've not voted yet, either.

Looking at who voted for Angelina (possible sheriff) and Simon (possible doctor)...we get, in alphabetical order...Karina, Rorri and Ufajamaya. Of course, if you include Leroy in the list, that drops to zero. We know Leroy was innocent because there were six mafia after that point, and that's a helluva lot. We probably didn't start with seven.

I think the voting is too spread out to wager any guesses from.
zorgoz 18 years ago
... so everyone voted for innocent folks last round.

I voted for Rorri
Tor 18 years ago
Except Jerele, the Dangerously Independent Thinker To Whom People Have Started To Listen.
zorgoz 18 years ago
that is Mr. Dangerously Independent Thinker To Whom People Have Started To Listen

Blackrabbit 18 years ago
Holy crap. I helped peg the SK (I told Pulvani and Tor and a few others I trusted what evidence I had)... the SK tries to misdirect suspicion onto me, the SK dies and I prove right, and you folks STILL think I'm mafia?

In-freaking-conceivable, lol.

I pointed arrows the other way because yes, that's what you do when you come under fire. And the people I pointed at are all people I think could be mafia. I don't claim to be right by any means. I have been forced into a defensive position in this game by a LOT of circumstantial evidence, when historically (feel free to research past mafias) I tend to sit on my hunches until I have enough to back them up.

This has made me play a little differently than usual. I apologize for the fact that I have been slinging arrows incorrectly in some cases (Simon) but I don't necessarily read the clues properly when rushed and at the time I thought my interpretation was correct.

Let me further point out that were I mafia it would be in the mafia's best interest to KEEP the SK alive for as long as possible so long as there's a better chance he or she will kill townies instead of mafia! If the mafia had known Rae was the SK you can bet your asses she'd still be alive and kicking.

You all seem to want an experienced player's opinion and I'm giving it. Read the clues!!

Uh, like I'm about to do since I just got home from work. :P

What I'd really like to know is who of the folks I told I tohught rae was the SK relayed that to her, cause I sure took a lot of heat afterwards. *narrows eyes* I'm watching damnit.
Blackrabbit 18 years ago
Folks the toad reference on Vudu is because I, his real life mother did in fact kiddingly tell him I would do just that in real life for the reason mentioned.

His bio says he tranfigures into a cobra not a toad. You can use that toad reference if you like but it is pretty weak since I know how it got in his bio.....

Please forgive me... if I'd known how it got in there I would have discounted it as evidence.

Incidentally, the toad reference in my own bio is only there because my dog is the doctor.


It's still in his bio, and therefore the reference is a valid clue, as it is in mine. I'm not arguing that, but it's pretty darn circumstantial. I see nothing in today's hit that implicates either Vudu or myself, and as I don't feel I have anything solid on him (and also don't see anything solid on me), I really haven't put too much focus on it and I dropped it. The townies need to work this out together, and stop fighting amongst ourselves.

Sometimes in this game, circumstance is exactly that... circumstance.
ROzbeans 18 years ago
/hiss at BR!
Just Erin 18 years ago
Cross posted from vote thread:
Rorri is being sandbagged, Dexter is mafia due to the 4 bodies mention (his goal is to date a girl from every house) and Poppy is the cook (Death Eaters, Grawp is hungry). Maybe I'm up in the night again. I think I'll vote for Dexter at this time.

Meh ... no. I disagree. Dexter's a townie, I'm certain of it. He's good at sniffing out theories, but you can go through his bio with a fine-toothed comb and none of it's adding up to the rest of the presumed clues.
Blackrabbit 18 years ago
I'm sorry roz.

Will you still bear my children?
Pulvani 18 years ago
Nono, you were supposed to /moo back at her.
Tor 18 years ago
*looks around, reads a special thermometer*

Yup. Hell just froze over. I agree with Emeraude.

Dexter doesn't have any real clues pointed at him. This far in it makes him a decent rallying point.
Vulash 18 years ago
You guys trying to get me hit tonight?
Blackrabbit 18 years ago
No shit. That was my thought.
Just Erin 18 years ago
WTF? Tor and I just both agreed that Dexter isn't Mafia. How is that trying to get you hit?
Vulash 18 years ago
Once I'm safe from assumption there is no chance at all of me getting lynched. Once that happens the mafia has to take me out. If there is a chance I can still get lynched then taking me out could end up a wasted hit for them. They know the doctor is dead, so I can't be saved - and I haven't really accused anyone today so I'm a very safe, and necessary mafia kill.
Vulash 18 years ago
I found it funny, I wasn't upset - not sure how it came across.