Battle School - The Mafia / Round 3 - /OOC / God 17 years ago

Round 3 - /OOC

Discuss here! OR I WILL SMITE THEE DOWN! For I am GOD! And I SMITE PEOPLE DOWN!

*whispered conference*

Except not so much any more. But I've still got it! Don't test me!

*smite*

Ha! Scared you!

CaptainBinky 17 years ago
Mafia Hit
The Battle School Mafia discussed this very thing while they waited for their next class to begin, seemingly joining in with the camaraderie that the rest of their army was trying to portray.

'Everything is ok.'

'Yeah, the teachers will figure it out and put a stop to it.'

'We're safe.'


If the logic was correct and there were 2 mafia left last round, then this certainly leads me to believe that Domo was a townie since we've still got a discussion going on.

Of course it could mean that the logic was incorrect. Not sure. That was just the first thing that grabbed me though (and the repetition of 2 last time round did seem like a big clue at the time).
pooka 17 years ago
The Lynch reference to how it was for Pinual and Theresa leads me to think Domo was the SK and that means the Chuck E. Cheese clue is still in play. I'll see if I can figure out how to host my sig on my lunch, today, by the way.

And you know what I think of the two mafia theory, that it refers to someone who is conspicuously part of a duo rather than meaning there is two mafia. We're still dealing with a pack. But I don't want to go off until I've had more time to look at the new material and know for sure if ya'll got the SK.
CaptainBinky 17 years ago
pooka;86716
The Lynch reference to how it was for Pinual and Theresa leads me to think Domo was the SK


I guess we'll find that out tonight ... Although I'm not sure if I follow your logic to how Domo was the SK. I still don't like the obviousness of the Shepard thing for Domo as SK.

pooka;86716
And you know what I think of the two mafia theory, that it refers to someone who is conspicuously part of a duo rather than meaning there is two mafia.


And you might very well be right there - especially with the whole wolf pack symbolism thing going on.
Rae 17 years ago
The lynch referenced everyone who died not just Pinual and Teresa. So, I don't think we can use that to determine whether Domo was mafia or SK. There is nothing that says we are voting tonight which there would normally be if the SK were dead. From that I believe that the SK is still alive.
CaptainBinky 17 years ago
Rae;86718
So, I don't think we can use that to determine whether Domo was mafia or SK.


...or townie. Don't forget option 3
Rae 17 years ago
Also, on the whole there were two left last round thing. The Mafia hit also said:

“ I know you two aren’t the only ones asking questions.”


That to me implies that there are more than the two present. No rule says that the mods have to use every character in every hit. Chances are there are clues though.
MEC 17 years ago
I don't know about anyone else, but Stormie dying in fantasy right before she died in real life the same way felt an awful lot like how Eduardo is living everything through a fictional world.
Den 17 years ago
Domo was mafia, and Eduardo is not.
This mafia kill looks to only contain ONE 'interloper", which, if you thought there were only two last time, confirms Domo was mafia.

This mafia hit has computer written all over it as well. Not to mention all the e mail references in the first hit...and who has the computer expertise? Armando.
FyreGarnett 17 years ago
While only one "interloper" killed Stormie, there were at least 2 talking before she was killed - which confuses the bejeesus outta me, especially with the pack references - though that could just be alluding to Dragon Army as a whole since they turn into them.

Has anyone figured out the tell that lets us know if a townie or a mafia has been taken? The only thing I've been able to see is that Domo's death seemed more accidental than deliberate, which could be a clue we messed that one up.
CaptainBinky 17 years ago
Den;86724
Domo was mafia...
This mafia kill looks to only contain ONE 'interloper", which, if you thought there were only two last time, confirms Domo was mafia.


Yes, one person does the kill, but there is clearly reference to at least 2 people talking...

Mafia Hit
The Battle School Mafia discussed this very thing


This is definately implying multiple people. So it seems likely that either:

  1. There are still 2 mafia remaining and if there were 2 last round, then Domo was not mafia

  2. There were more than 2 mafia last round, there are still at least 2 this round... Domo may or may not have been mafia and there is another explanation for all the 2 reference.
What is clear to me, is that we cannot be 100% sure that Domo was mafia. I am confused by your conviction.

Den;86724
and Eduardo is not


Yay!
MEC 17 years ago
Sitting up in her bed, Stormie shook her head. 'What the hell?'


I couldn't stop noticing that this part rhymes. I looked in the profiles for anything to do with poetry and I found that Ezekial makes Haikus as well as other bad poetry. I'm going to look and see if there are any Haikus anywhere, but I'm not that great at poetry.
Den 17 years ago
Correction - Eduardo could be the godfather. I missed a point earlier. :P

Also, I see now that there could have been two mafia involved in the last hit - one in her game, and one out of it.
pooka 17 years ago
Who would Stormie have been suprised to learn was mafia? I hope that doesn't mean we just lost our Sherrif.
CaptainBinky 17 years ago
Den;86724
Domo was mafia, and Eduardo is not.

Den;86724
Eduardo could be the godfather


me
I am confused by your conviction.


This all rather sounds to me like you're insinuating that you're the Sheriff, since only he would be sure who would or would not be mafia (and of course the Godfather IDs as townie).

This seems like a strange strategy since you'd be putting yourself in the firing line for a mafia hit.

Unless of course, you have some reason to feel safe from the mafia...?

Just a thought.
Mike 17 years ago
OK guys I’m at work so you’ll forgive me if this is brief, slap dash and less than convincing but this hit is the second one to very clearly mention a game, in fact this time Stormie had been dreaming about the –fantasy- game not to mention day one’s clue about ‘a real section eight’ Eduardo has his fantasy world and
If Eduardo should ever be dragged forcefully out of his fantasy world it would likely do him serious psychological damage.
which would sure qualify as section eight in my book then we have the day one clue about the mafia trickling in… a reference to water maybe? and Eduardo is also from Wellstaple on the water

Obviously I need to look harder at this but that will have to wait until I get home.
Den 17 years ago
I'm not insinuating anything - believe what you will. You are the one who is dancing around me possibly being the sheriff, and then you turn back around and infer I might be mafia...I'm surprised you didn't also include the possibility I'm a townie! Nothing like covering all your bases, except that really doesn't help any of us find the killers.

Is anyone going to start talking about the clues? Am I the only one who sees the computer connections to Armando?

So far all we've talked about here today is how many mafia are left, and theories of who is involved. Have we given up on looking and providing clues? Heck - Domo's out of the picture, so at least we don't have to go through his bio again! (lol - j/k - it was an interesting bio, even if EXTREMELY long)
CaptainBinky 17 years ago
Den;86743
IYou are the one who is dancing around me possibly being the sheriff, and then you turn back around and infer I might be mafia...I'm surprised you didn't also include the possibility I'm a townie!


No, I'm saying that you're insinuating that you're the Sheriff.

If I'm dancing around, it's well and truly on top of one conclusion, not multiple.

Den;86743
Nothing like covering all your bases, except that really doesn't help any of us find the killers.


Doesn't it?

Den;86743
Is anyone going to start talking about the clues? Am I the only one who sees the computer connections to Armando?


But yes, clues. I'm going to have a proper root around later on but initially, there does seem to be a nice computer connection.
MEC 17 years ago
“No, I don’t buy that. What happened with Pinual…no, I don’t accept…”


correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't this a haiku?
CaptainBinky 17 years ago
Good Lord, you're right!

5 - 7 - 5
MashPotato 17 years ago
I believe "Pinual" only has 2 syllables, like "Pin-wall"