ROUND 4 OOC

Between the scars/joker, chef/money in mouth, and organ transplant / disemboweled dude I guess I'm on board again this round.

That plus the fact that Boris is wearing a suit, tie and gaiters.

The joker wore a suit, tie and spats which are similar to gaiters. So that could explain why (along with the scars) he reminded his victim of the joker.

OMG...

Of course...

You're all wrong, but whatevs. Once again you've allowed the shill of logic and intelligence to pull the wool over your eyes. I wear gators, as in ALLIGATOR shoes, not gaiters as in spats. I know the diff, do you?

At any rate, check out the experts we have in the bank, I think that's more telling...

Right off the bat we have:

Reginald Fleischer the Mathematician who is wearing...guess what...off color green. Just sayin'.

Read the hit again, and peruse the part about experts in a narrow field. Narrow minded, expert in his field. You folks are gonna let Vulash run off with another Mafia win...sigh.

I do agree with some of your points, most certainly.

Seems pretty weak to me unless you care to quote the off color green clue you're referring too

So your repost to a possible clue is to change the clue's context from spats to a direct animal reference (and simultaneously throw a hissy fit)?

There is now a stack of things pointing at you.

Doing some clue-digging to deflect the evidence would help your cause a lot more than getting pissy. ;)

Oh there were clues pointing at Boris for every hit...We were gonna let you die of natural causes but you decided to come back so now you must die!

Slipsnish & karieth are both voting Reginald/Vulash again, yet I see no ooc chat with damning clues for why they would go that way...

Surely mafia would work together to protect their own and the GF. But to hide the GF they would vote randomly. So why the directed move on Reginald (it happened in the previous vote also.)

With the lack of a sheriff to step forward, the 'plan' has somewhat lost it's sheen. But it still has merits.

And the real question now is why two people are opting to bump off Reginald/Vulash without stating any clues as to why?

I show Wystro as voting for Ella. Keriath has voted for Reginald every single time, and I proposed a theory in last round's OOC, or the round before, which will probbaly make you suspect me, but I'll repeat the basic idea here:

I think Keriath got a Townie role and just doesn't want to participate fully. Plus, nobody trusts Vulash. Either that, or he has some "other" role, and is just hiding in the shadows biding his time, trying not to draw attention to himself.

As for the second part of your post... I spent too long in the sun today, and the combination of too many pain pills and it being 1:27 am is making it difficult for me to even understand the question. Maybe I'll offer a suggestion tomorrow!

Yeah, the Wystro count was a fault by me. I've corrected that now. :)

As for Keriath, before roles were even assigned he stated that Vulash needed to die asap. He may be mafia, but i suspect he's a townie. As for Slip, there are a couple reasons he could have voted that way but I suspect it was simply to vote the person that was ringleading against the mafia.

The continued votes for a vulash lynch with no reasoning behind them are highly suspicious.

The voting pattern we have followed based on the original plan has always been backed by the apparent incriminating evidence (in abundance!).

And the additional knowledge that it's from the same two makes me think that we did well, and only a couple of mafia survive.

If there really are only a couple of mafia left, surely it would be highly unlikely they would vote in a way which separates them from the rest of us. More likely is that given the number of votes means that Boris can't possibly be saved, they would just resign themselves to losing him and vote along with the townies.

Blinky:


Yeeeah...but the same thing happened last round. If we're actually lynching mafia (which...we -have- to be, right?) there's some reason that the mafia is being so cavalier about losing its people. Maybe...

- There is a very large mafia and they can afford to lose several people and still win
- They are not interested in the numbers aspect of the game - they don't want to win by having more people and taking over the vote, they want to win by killing people
- The individuals in the mafia are all team players and all too eager to take one for the team
- There is dissension in the ranks and certain mafia are all too eager to take out the mafia members who disagree with them
- They see themselves as not having any option (again)
- They have one or even two people who haven't been clued yet and/or are otherwise untouchable in some way, so they're throwing all their resources at protecting them

It's that last that worries me most. Hold nothing sacred! No one is above suspicion! Constant vigilance!

Also in the interest of full disclosure and constant vigilance I think the joker clue could potentially point to Nicole, who wears a lot of make up and is interested in make up as a career field. I still think Boris is guilty and the facial scars are the strongest clue tie-in though.

That "constant vigilance" bit is a nice line to throw back in our faces, should you turn out to be Mafia, and win. :P

The plan isn't dead yet - give me just a little longer