ROUND 5 discussion (OOC)
Lynch - Boris
Mafia - Jayden

Vulash
14 years ago
Ok - Myraan needs to die. I have to go smoke and then I'll make a lengthy post of why.

nickenstien
14 years ago
This is a cut'n'paste from what I mentioned yesterday (as Pharren is being too lazy to check who has what in their possession
):
From Ksagag's profile:
Jayden was indeed fooled by the appearance of one of the mafia!
She is carrying a compact/mirror. You can certainly cut people up with the edge of a mirror.
And again, with Kilhandra:
from her bio:
She is also carrying a compact mirror.

From Ksagag's profile:
Ksagag
She is a petite girl, but you can't let her size fool you.
Jayden was indeed fooled by the appearance of one of the mafia!
She is carrying a compact/mirror. You can certainly cut people up with the edge of a mirror.
And again, with Kilhandra:
from her bio:
Kilhandra
5'3" tall, slender, to some a little too thin
She is also carrying a compact mirror.

Vulash
14 years ago
It bothers me that you post clues (that could fit FAR more than 2 people) against someone after they vote for you. It also bothers me that you edited your post to try to make Pharren look defensive after the fact. Regardless, I'm not sold on you as mafia yet - and I'm going to save you.
nickenstien;98688
This is a cut'n'paste from what I mentioned yesterday (as Pharren is being too lazy to check who has what in their possession):
From Ksagag's profile:
Jayden was indeed fooled by the appearance of one of the mafia!
She is carrying a compact/mirror. You can certainly cut people up with the edge of a mirror.
And again, with Kilhandra:
from her bio:
She is also carrying a compact mirror.
It bothers me that you post clues (that could fit FAR more than 2 people) against someone after they vote for you. It also bothers me that you edited your post to try to make Pharren look defensive after the fact. Regardless, I'm not sold on you as mafia yet - and I'm going to save you.

Vulash
14 years ago
Reasons Myraan should be lynched:
-She's small (so are a lot of people, but it fits the mold of at least 2 possibly 3 of the mafia from the last kill scene
-green eyes (wasn't there a jealously look in a previous hit? This might be a bum clue not sure)
- CONSTANT MOTHERFUCKING TWITCHING THAT HAS BEEN IN ALMOST? EVERY MAFIA HIT
- OCD tendancies - twitching, and a perfect purse - the other other person this really fits is me, but there was definitely a clean theme in the first few hits. She definitely has a "clean/organized" theme going on with her character
- Tattooed Fingers - I still think Kal's finger rubbing was a clue, and if it wasn't Boris it was probably the fingers here
- she has a compact - could snap and be used to cut - there were also heavy reflection scenes in the first 2 kills
- She's into drugs - cocaine reference? Seems weird but possible
- starving artist - constant food themes that don't refer Boris apparently, and fits the artistic motif
- psychiatrist card
- constant references to the number 3
Ok that's just the bio. Now I implore you to go back and read the first 2 OOCs - keeping in mind nadiya was mafia. First: The voting pattern fits. She voted: Olivia (a story here too), Didn't vote, Kal (when we hung Nadiya), and boris.
First she posted a super long post in OOC 1 that ONLY incriminated Verileah based on numbers. Once it was obvious Verileah wasn't going to get hung she posted again based on ONE CLUE an entire list of small females with some facts about each. Despite the fact that on HER OWN list there were far more clues pointing at others - she said that after looking that over she was now convinced it was Olivia. In that list Nadiya is listed with a ton of clues.
I said early on that you might be able to tell mafia by looking at WHO certain people did NOT incriminate. Constantly posting large posts that only look at one or two clues and point at a fwe people only is a good way to deflect blame as mafia because you can focus on clues that aren't real.
In day 2 OOC she posted another long post focusing on a few clues that pointed only at Nickenstein, gongaa, and Kal Mundo. She is also the one that brought up that we were only hanging females - a good way to get the focus off of you.
In day 3 OOC she tried to stretch out the weird cocaine reference. She was very defensive when Nichole and I pointed this out. She got defensive as h ell after the plan (that alone is understandable), and then made another post to implicate Kal Mundo again. SHe also had attempted to vote for the Professor. This entire time her list of people she points fingers at is very small.
And Finally: After rereading ALL of nadiya's OOC posts I can't find anywhere (maybe one small one that is blown off?) where she ever implicated Myraan.
I think there was more, but this post got long. In short - I'm voting for Myraan.
-She's small (so are a lot of people, but it fits the mold of at least 2 possibly 3 of the mafia from the last kill scene
-green eyes (wasn't there a jealously look in a previous hit? This might be a bum clue not sure)
- CONSTANT MOTHERFUCKING TWITCHING THAT HAS BEEN IN ALMOST? EVERY MAFIA HIT
- OCD tendancies - twitching, and a perfect purse - the other other person this really fits is me, but there was definitely a clean theme in the first few hits. She definitely has a "clean/organized" theme going on with her character
- Tattooed Fingers - I still think Kal's finger rubbing was a clue, and if it wasn't Boris it was probably the fingers here
- she has a compact - could snap and be used to cut - there were also heavy reflection scenes in the first 2 kills
- She's into drugs - cocaine reference? Seems weird but possible
- starving artist - constant food themes that don't refer Boris apparently, and fits the artistic motif
- psychiatrist card
- constant references to the number 3
Ok that's just the bio. Now I implore you to go back and read the first 2 OOCs - keeping in mind nadiya was mafia. First: The voting pattern fits. She voted: Olivia (a story here too), Didn't vote, Kal (when we hung Nadiya), and boris.
First she posted a super long post in OOC 1 that ONLY incriminated Verileah based on numbers. Once it was obvious Verileah wasn't going to get hung she posted again based on ONE CLUE an entire list of small females with some facts about each. Despite the fact that on HER OWN list there were far more clues pointing at others - she said that after looking that over she was now convinced it was Olivia. In that list Nadiya is listed with a ton of clues.
I said early on that you might be able to tell mafia by looking at WHO certain people did NOT incriminate. Constantly posting large posts that only look at one or two clues and point at a fwe people only is a good way to deflect blame as mafia because you can focus on clues that aren't real.
In day 2 OOC she posted another long post focusing on a few clues that pointed only at Nickenstein, gongaa, and Kal Mundo. She is also the one that brought up that we were only hanging females - a good way to get the focus off of you.
In day 3 OOC she tried to stretch out the weird cocaine reference. She was very defensive when Nichole and I pointed this out. She got defensive as h ell after the plan (that alone is understandable), and then made another post to implicate Kal Mundo again. SHe also had attempted to vote for the Professor. This entire time her list of people she points fingers at is very small.
And Finally: After rereading ALL of nadiya's OOC posts I can't find anywhere (maybe one small one that is blown off?) where she ever implicated Myraan.
I think there was more, but this post got long. In short - I'm voting for Myraan.

Vulash
14 years ago
And I want to throw one other unrelated thing out:
Nadiya kept posting in OOC's stuff like "I'm busy I'll clue search later" and then when she did it was always short and at a few people. Myraan's was simliar, but without the busy aspect. I think we should keep our eyes on others with similar trends as that may be an overlying strategy this game by the mafia.
Nadiya kept posting in OOC's stuff like "I'm busy I'll clue search later" and then when she did it was always short and at a few people. Myraan's was simliar, but without the busy aspect. I think we should keep our eyes on others with similar trends as that may be an overlying strategy this game by the mafia.

nickenstien
14 years ago
That was a response to Pharren, regarding the compact mirror. Which _two_ people have.
And both of those compact-carriers perfectly fit the "Jayden didn't find them physically intimidating" motif.
I don't see what is so left field about that idea.
Also, this is inaccurate. I posted some clues, had a bit of sleep, woke up, had few more thoughts and made an edit. Then went back to bed. Failing to hit refresh (and it being the middle of the night (I'm in England)), I didn't even know that Pharren had replied when I made that edit.
Vulash
It bothers me that you post clues (that could fit FAR more than 2 people) against someone after they vote for you.
That was a response to Pharren, regarding the compact mirror. Which _two_ people have.
And both of those compact-carriers perfectly fit the "Jayden didn't find them physically intimidating" motif.
I don't see what is so left field about that idea.
Vulash
It also bothers me that you edited your post to try to make Pharren look defensive after the fact. Regardless, I'm not sold on you as mafia yet - and I'm going to save you.
Also, this is inaccurate. I posted some clues, had a bit of sleep, woke up, had few more thoughts and made an edit. Then went back to bed. Failing to hit refresh (and it being the middle of the night (I'm in England)), I didn't even know that Pharren had replied when I made that edit.

Vulash
14 years ago
I don't understand - you posted at 8:46ish pm, then responded to Pharren at 9
5PM, then edited your post at 9:30PM. How did you respond to him and THEN edit your post to include him and not realize? Then 2 hours later you said look at the knee jerk reactions - all in reference to his one post (that was half joking) made before your first response and subsequent edit?
nickenstien;98697
That was a response to Pharren, regarding the compact mirror. Which _two_ people have.
And both of those compact-carriers perfectly fit the "Jayden didn't find them physically intimidating" motif.
I don't see what is so left field about that idea.
Also, this is inaccurate. I posted some clues, had a bit of sleep, woke up, had few more thoughts and made an edit. Then went back to bed. Failing to hit refresh (and it being the middle of the night (I'm in England)), I didn't even know that Pharren had replied when I made that edit.
I don't understand - you posted at 8:46ish pm, then responded to Pharren at 9


nickenstien
14 years ago
I have sleep issues.
It's 5am here. I was asleep 20 mins ago, and will possibly sleep for a bit and be awake again in an hour.
But this is irrelevant. What is relevant is that we have two people holding compact mirrors, which fit the bill of the murder weapon (thicker than a knife), who also fall in nicely with the "Not physically intimidating to Jayden" theme.
It's 5am here. I was asleep 20 mins ago, and will possibly sleep for a bit and be awake again in an hour.
But this is irrelevant. What is relevant is that we have two people holding compact mirrors, which fit the bill of the murder weapon (thicker than a knife), who also fall in nicely with the "Not physically intimidating to Jayden" theme.

Verileah
14 years ago
You can sleep BACKWARD IN TIME!?

Vulash
14 years ago
That doesn't explain how you posted, he posted - you responded to him and THEN edited your post to include him (meaning you had seen his post) and you're saying you didn't know he had posted

pharren
14 years ago
What? lol. How stupid do you think we are?
11:46 -- You post some weird thing about shirt color and Vulash as the Godfather with an all-girl hit squad (I like the imagery this evokes, btw, I see a total '70s thing with Vulash in bellbottoms and an afro with like Charlie's Angels or some shit posing behind him)
12:17 -- I post a what-I-thought-was funny imitation of your post accusing Vulash, containing some actual possible clues, and then I make the two de-twizzler prototype jokes.
12
5 -- You reply with a funny post of your own.
12:30 -- You go back and edit your post to add my name all over the place.
2
1 -- "OH MY! Look at the knee-jerk reactions I just caused! I even went to the length of pointing out how some of this could implicate me! And still Pharren and others took huge offence and then followed with the lamest rebutalls in all mafia-game history! Vulash and Pharren, safe?!? Think again people... "
(next day) 12:07 -- "I didn't even know that Pharren had replied when I made that edit."
???
I didn't even know that Pharren had replied when I made that edit.
What? lol. How stupid do you think we are?
11:46 -- You post some weird thing about shirt color and Vulash as the Godfather with an all-girl hit squad (I like the imagery this evokes, btw, I see a total '70s thing with Vulash in bellbottoms and an afro with like Charlie's Angels or some shit posing behind him)
12:17 -- I post a what-I-thought-was funny imitation of your post accusing Vulash, containing some actual possible clues, and then I make the two de-twizzler prototype jokes.
12

12:30 -- You go back and edit your post to add my name all over the place.
2

(next day) 12:07 -- "I didn't even know that Pharren had replied when I made that edit."
???

Ksagag
14 years ago
I am with you Vulash. I have been leaning towards Myraan for a LONG time and I think with everything laid out and re-reading everything it all points towards her. Yes, there are things that could point towards me, everyone can take these as they will, but I can tell everyone they'd be making a huge mistake wasting a lynch on me.
I just think clues towards other people add up a lot better then me being small, having a mirror, etc. I really don't want to sit and defend myself, because that's not how I want to spend my time playing this game. I'm looking at all the options and staying as open-minded as possible.
I will also be voting for Myraan. Vulash pretty much summed up everything I was thinking, I just didn't have time to type it all out because I was in class all night.
I just think clues towards other people add up a lot better then me being small, having a mirror, etc. I really don't want to sit and defend myself, because that's not how I want to spend my time playing this game. I'm looking at all the options and staying as open-minded as possible.
I will also be voting for Myraan. Vulash pretty much summed up everything I was thinking, I just didn't have time to type it all out because I was in class all night.

Wystro
14 years ago
Vulash's interpretation of the clues makes sense to me this round, and I have no real reason to doubt the logic of his choice. I'm voting Myraan/Kilandra. *crosses fingers*

Ksagag
14 years ago
I think a metal spatula fits the "bill of the murder weapon" even better then a broken compact mirror.
nickenstien;98699
But this is irrelevant. What is relevant is that we have two people holding compact mirrors, which fit the bill of the murder weapon (thicker than a knife), who also fall in nicely with the "Not physically intimidating to Jayden" theme.
I think a metal spatula fits the "bill of the murder weapon" even better then a broken compact mirror.

nickenstien
14 years ago
GREAT SCOTT!
Verileah;98700
You can sleep BACKWARD IN TIME!?
GREAT SCOTT!

nickenstien
14 years ago
I have no idea on that one.
Like I said before, my sleep is _really_ messed up. Anything I say during the night could be done half-asleep with me having no memory of it in the morning.
But those clue tie-ins still seem pertinent.
pharren;98702
What? lol. How stupid do you think we are?
I have no idea on that one.

Like I said before, my sleep is _really_ messed up. Anything I say during the night could be done half-asleep with me having no memory of it in the morning.
But those clue tie-ins still seem pertinent.

Verileah
14 years ago
Nick you are also kind of awesome.
Edit - except that wasn't very nice! Back to the Future References = good, backhandedly calling people stupid = bad *spanks Nick*
Edit - except that wasn't very nice! Back to the Future References = good, backhandedly calling people stupid = bad *spanks Nick*

nickenstien
14 years ago
Hugs! xoxo
Verileah;98709
Nick you are also kind of awesome.
Hugs! xoxo


Vulash
14 years ago
EDIT:

Vulash
14 years ago
Anyway - point is I think Myraan is guilty. Hopefully a hell of a lot more guilty than boris turned out to be.