Angels & Demons Mafia / ROUND 5 discussion (OOC) / ROzbeans 14 years ago

ROUND 5 discussion (OOC)

Lynch - Boris
Mafia - Jayden

Verileah 14 years ago

Good scene Roz.

Also: Fuck.

Verileah 14 years ago

*coughs* with that out of the way - to me it reads that Myraan was a demon/townie. I still feel there was a fuckton of stuff pointed her way, but now I'm thinking we need to reevaluate the way we look at clues. I still like matching up suspects against the little profile page that I made. If I die in the next little bit, maybe someone can add to it and make connections I haven't made?

We're for real hosed if we can't nab a mafia player next lynch, guys

Ksagag 14 years ago

GRRR I was sooo sure Myraan was/is mafia!! WTF is going on??

Verileah 14 years ago

So, finger pointing before I get killed maybe:
Wystro and Nicole: These two jumped on board practically the moment Vulash suggested who to lynch. This makes me paranoid.

Nicole has a lot of those wordy clues pointed her way, but her behavior seems townie up until recently. She fits into the profile of a mafia by way of being reminiscent of the joker (which we’re unsure about as a clue) and possibly as the non conformist of the bunch, saying the out-there quotes. She may also desire fame, but the fame thing in one of the hits could have referred only to Nadiya. I think that the ‘take it as you will’ attitude and having no desire to defend one’s self is a strategy, but have no way of knowing whether it’s a strategy to stay alive as a townie or to dismiss claims as a mafia, heh.

Wystro has had a few wordy things thrown his way. ShutUpSara has implied a positive ID, but without knowing whether she’s for real the sheriff is there’s no way to take that seriously. He is bald, and he is a genteel old man who I can easily see calling someone Miss. I think the ‘I’m new and need someone to tell me what to do’ line is a strategy, but, again, have no way of knowing if it’s a mafia ploy or just someone honestly being new to the game.

Greywood 14 years ago

Yup, it seems she was a demon/townie afterall, since she's not going to a better place. All i can say is...I R SCARED!

Vulash 14 years ago

Verileah;98760

So, finger pointing before I get killed maybe:
Wystro and Nicole: These two jumped on board practically the moment Vulash suggested who to lynch. This makes me paranoid.

Nicole has a lot of those wordy clues pointed her way, but her behavior seems townie up until recently. She fits into the profile of a mafia by way of being reminiscent of the joker (which we’re unsure about as a clue) and possibly as the non conformist of the bunch, saying the out-there quotes. She may also desire fame, but the fame thing in one of the hits could have referred only to Nadiya. I think that the ‘take it as you will’ attitude and having no desire to defend one’s self is a strategy, but have no way of knowing whether it’s a strategy to stay alive as a townie or to dismiss claims as a mafia, heh.

Wystro has had a few wordy things thrown his way. ShutUpSara has implied a positive ID, but without knowing whether she’s for real the sheriff is there’s no way to take that seriously. He is bald, and he is a genteel old man who I can easily see calling someone Miss. I think the ‘I’m new and need someone to tell me what to do’ line is a strategy, but, again, have no way of knowing if it’s a mafia ploy or just someone honestly being new to the game.

When did she imply wystro IDed mafia? Did I miss it or forget it? Also - she also implied she was not playing anymore, and keeps posting - but never changed the early "I won't have time to vote for someone or read ooc/clues" vote so I'm hesitant.

Verileah 14 years ago

You don't think voting for a guy based on 'intuition' is a shutupsara-style hint (because it would just be silly for the sheriff to speak plainly, have to speak in clues!). It certainly fits with the PMs you got from her.

If I were sold on her being the sheriff this would be much more compelling.

Wystro 14 years ago

I agree with Verileah in the sense that we need to shake up the way that we're looking at things, and perhaps look at people a second time and in a new light. ShutUpSarah voted for me, and that's what Verileah means, I believe, to be her ID of me as mafia.

Vulash 14 years ago

I really don't think she's the sheriff.

So I read that as most likely we got a townie - though it isn't as clear as the others I guess.

I think its time to go after a man - I don't understand the distrust of Wystro at all. I"ve seen hardly any clues at others.

I"m thinking:

Gongaa
Nickenstein
Vudu

Would be the top choices based on clues, but I'm not sold on any of them. I was more convinced of Myraan so I'm a little fucking confused. I'm open to suggestions for sure.

Vulash 14 years ago

Well cross the professor off the list. As if that wasn't a completely obvious choice after he argued with Pharren and myself.

Verileah 14 years ago

Yeah I'm on the fence with Wystro, just 'roused my suspicions is all.

Poor Nick

.

Have to mull over suspects, I'm doubting everything now.

Ksagag 14 years ago

Verileah;98760

So, finger pointing before I get killed maybe:
Nicole has a lot of those wordy clues pointed her way, but her behavior seems townie up until recently. She fits into the profile of a mafia by way of being reminiscent of the joker (which we’re unsure about as a clue) and possibly as the non conformist of the bunch, saying the out-there quotes. She may also desire fame, but the fame thing in one of the hits could have referred only to Nadiya. I think that the ‘take it as you will’ attitude and having no desire to defend one’s self is a strategy, but have no way of knowing whether it’s a strategy to stay alive as a townie or to dismiss claims as a mafia, heh.

Just wondering how my behavior seemed townie up until recently...? Because I stated I didn't want to sit and defend a couple clues that I think are insignificant when compared with some of the others? I am a little confused on the whole Myraan thing because I was sure we had her. But I did not 'jump on the bandwagon' as soon as Vulash posted his plan. He just reiterated everything I was thinking already and apparently we had similar plans. He just chose to take control and voice his, acting as a sort of leader. I don't feel comfortable doing something like that because I have never played before and was trying to feel this game out.
If Vulash happens to be mafia, well then fuck. I would be totally wrong in who I think is who, but it wouldn't be because I am following him. I have my own clues and opinions I'm basing my votes on.
I have been trying to stay as active as possible in hopes I can learn how to plan the game and find out who the mafia so we can get them the hell out of here!

Anyways, gonna do some clue-digging. Will post my thoughts in a bit.

nickenstien 14 years ago

Vulash;98770

Well cross the professor off the list. As if that wasn't a completely obvious choice after he argued with Pharren and myself.

Have I missed something?

Edit: Oh do you mean Goonga's vote? I only just saw that now.

Vudu 14 years ago

yea your dead you need to only post in the ghost thread...

nickenstien 14 years ago

Eh? What?

I see no Mafia-hit post?

EDIT: Sorry for posting here. I had no idea I was dead.

ROzbeans 14 years ago

My bad, I fixed it =D