ROUND 6 - OOC dicussion

You can think whatever you want about me, but keep comments based in-game, don't make shit personal. Calling me a "nutcase" because I don't agree with you is a childish move, and I consider it an attack on my person, not my character. I've done nothing to deserve a personal attack. I'm not going to make judgments about anyone's actual persona based off of their actions in the game, why should you?

In another vein, I've released information about what SKIDs I have done to an individual.

I will say the only Mafia I've positively ID'd was Boris. Everyone else I've ID'd was killed by Mafia. I missed SKID this week.

You guys can do with this information what you will.

I'm pretty sure it's a pointless exercise getting Sara lynched for playing differently (call it what you will) than the rest of us. If she *is* a townie, then lynching her is just one step closer to a mafia victory regardless of how she chooses to vote. And if she's mafia - well, she's not voting along with the rest of the mafia either so that makes it all rather harmless enough.

What I do know though, is that there seems to be only rather circumstantial evidence pointing towards her. The Joker scar thing I'm pretty sure is irrelevant since her scars are specifically "barely noticeable". So unless there's something damning I'm missing...

/goes back to the drawing board, trawls through the threads again

I would venture a guess that he called you a nutcase because one day you post about how you "love to claim you are this or that" then the next day you claim to be the sheriff and so pro that you've never lost a game played outside the boards. Then you say you are going to ID Wystro or myself, and if you are the sheriff you already have my ID...why have i not recieved a PM? The point is, if you were really the sheriff you would start to have an idea of who is who and start networking with people. If you got 3 townie IDs after 3 rounds only 1 could possibly be the GF, so you'd trust the other 2 or at least send out feelers to try and glean more info.

This is my first ever game of mafia and your "logic" on the playstyle is ..erratic at best. Right now it seems like you have basically gone off the deep end and decided that "fine lynch me, but i wont' be helping the townies unless I'm about to be lynched"...which makes no sense because if you are a townie and the mafia hit you then how the hell are we supposed to gain anything from the IDs that you NEVER shared. Right now we think we have 4 mafia and 7 townies. Does that mean you haven't ID'd any mafia at all? then at worst you could have come up with the GF but then everyone else you talk to would still be watching everyone else that ID'd not mafia and maybe they could figure out who the hell the GF is in the group.

I don't think you are mafia because you have been contradicting yourself on the forums over and over and I wouldn't think the GF would want you to be drawing attention like that...unless the GF wants chaos. The other options are you are a townie or actually the sheriff that doesn't have a network going and thats not helping. I don't know your strategy and at this point don't really care. If you choose to NOT help then you will most likely get lynched.

You ID'ed Boris as mafia?

... Ignore me posting my results, it's fine. No problem.

And you all wonder why I don't play along... Fine. I'll just not post on OOC anymore, and just do RP with myself and... Roz, at this point lol

I would disagree really - I think we should be going for the person most likely to be mafia - regardless of whether they are working with the other mafia or not. We can't afford more than one more wrong lynch, and buying another night gives us more to work with

Now if the mafia could just confirm that for us, we'd know for certain one way or the other :D

@Vulash: Yeah but is she really the most likely mafia at this point? There's bollocks all evidence pointing at her that I can see. I rather suspect that if we listed people in order of damning evidence and voted clinically, Sara would be somewhat towards the bottom end of the list.

I responded - did you say you ID'ed boris as "mafia"? That would be - big.

Yay, refreshing pages! >.<

And if I'm really the most likely to be Mafia, based off of the clues given.. I don't think you're looking at the clues subjectively.

There is more to it, but as long as you are tight lipped on the IDs then I can't say anymore. That isn't me being stubborn - it's just the fact of the way things have played out to this point.

We'll see it all at the end of the game :D

The last argument I'll make on the subject of who to lynch. I don't know why I said that I'll probably argue more, but another point! When we lynched Nichole there was subtle resistance - right after "the plan" and she was mafia. When we lynched Boris, and Myraan - it went over baby butt smooth - everyone was on board, and they were townies. Now for lynching sara it seems like there is resistance even though we're fairly certain she isn't the sheriff, and the joker clue (which was one of the few "LOOK AT ME I"M A REAL CLUE" clues we've had) seems to point most at her.

I just want a mafia - so I'm open to hear more arguments - Binky's have been pretty good, but I'm not sure who else you're recommending Binky?

Keriath, Greywood, Gongaa. You like any of those?

Gongaa I've seen clues for but haven't felt like the OOC matched.

Greywood - basically just the ambiguous cocaine reference, but without all the other stuff Sara has - So I like Sara better

Keriath - not many clues - just votes for me nightly

Honestly I've seen more clues for you than Greywood or Keriath, but Gongaa has had quite a few

Do you disagree with my previous points on these three?

I disagree that the scars on the throat strongly connects Sara to the joker.

There has been so much said I'm not sure what your previous points were - I disagree with the connections to Keriath for sure. I think he's slightly suspicious for the fact that he is reading these afterall, but I'm just not seeing the clues.

We didn't lynch Nicole, we lynched Nadiya.

Yea, thats twice he said Nichole when he meant Nadiya.